Is global fertility already below the replacement rate?
Core argument: Correcting for excess births, the world total fertility rate in 2024 is estimated at around 2.17 against a replacement rate of about 2.21, placing humanity already below replacement.
Correcting for excess births, the world TFR in 2024 is likely to be around 2.17 instead of 2.25. The world replacement rate is around 2.21. So, we estimate that humanity is already below the replacement rate. We are entering a whole new world: fertility and births are falling much faster than anyone anticipated. There is a good chance that the TFR of middle-income countries (e.g., Colombia, Chile, Thailand, Turkey) will fall below the TFR of rich countries (at least outside East Asia). Migration will exacerbate the situation: Colombia’s population is already declining due to high migration to the U.S. and Spain. This creates a whole range of challenges. Middle-income countries may not have the margins of maneuver that Japan has. Once you start thinking about these issues, it is hard to think about anything else: demography is destiny. The number of immigrants that the advanced would need to bring is phenomenal, causing multiple strains in society. We live in a welfare state, and this is unlikely to change anytime soon.

