Is the Fed wrong to blame inflation mainly on tariffs and goods?
Core argument: Consumer goods prices were rising about 2% a year on the eve of the war with Iran and accelerating, against flat prices in 2024 and annual declines of roughly 0.5%–1% in the years immediately preceding the pandemic.
Perhaps the most striking thing about Powell’s Wednesday press conference was the repeated—and wrong—insistence that excessive inflation was mostly about rising goods prices, which in turn were mostly about tariffs. To be fair, goods inflation was getting worse [prior to] the Iran conflict, and in some significant categories was worse than in the 2021H2-2022H1 price spike. In the years immediately preceding the pandemic, consumer goods prices regularly fell about 0.5%-1% each year. In 2024, those prices were flat. As of the eve of the war with Iran, consumer goods prices were rising by about 2% a year—and the pace was accelerating. Services represent the bulk of economic activity, and should be making Fed officials worry that their 2% inflation target is out of reach. Prices of services purchased by businesses as inputs to their production have been accelerating rapidly in the past few months. Stage 2 services inflation would likely be even faster if not for the fact that the official price of “business loans” is falling by 25% a year, the fastest rate on record outside of the pandemic. On the consumer side, the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index for services excluding imputed prices, housing (which has known issues with measurement lags), and utilities (which can be volatile and mask underlying trends) has actually been accelerating recently.

