Does a shrinking money supply produce deflation?
Core argument: M2 shrank at an annual rate of almost 5% a year earlier, the first contraction in the money supply in sixty years, yet inflation has been excessive rather than deflationary.
If money supply growth should cause inflation when money supply growth is unusually high, then the logical consequence must be that money supply growth should also cause low inflation/deflation when money supply growth is very low. And indeed, money supply growth has been historically low recently. In fact, the money supply has shrunk for the first time in sixty years. We should have deflation, but we have not. Instead, we have too much inflation. Since M2 shrank at an annual rate of almost 5% a year ago, with the 15-month lag that correlated with the inflation outbreak, we should have severe deflation in the next few months. Not “just” the 2% deflation we experienced during the financial crisis. No, severe deflation, because the money supply has been shrinking at a historic pace. As you can imagine, I am skeptical, to say the least.

