Does diverting teen defendants from adult courts increase youth crime?
Core argument: New York City recorded 4,858 major crimes in which a minor was accused or arrested last year, up 37% from 3,543 in 2017, according to Police Department figures.
The number of people under 18 accused of major crimes has increased sharply in New York City in the past seven years, Police Department figures show. Last year, there were 4,858 major crimes where a minor was accused or arrested, up from 3,543 in 2017 — a 37% increase. The seven index crimes are murder, rape, robbery, felony assault, burglary, grand larceny and grand larceny of automobiles. Many of the crimes have continued to increase dramatically in 2024, particularly robberies and felony assaults. Through Oct. 1, there were arrests for 969 felony assaults and 2,019 robberies, a 17% increase from the same time last year. Until recently, the criminal justice system in New York treated many young people accused of serious crimes as adults. But in 2017, when youth crime had fallen to lows not seen for decades, legislators in Albany changed the way the cases of 16- and 17-year-olds were handled, passing a law known as “Raise the Age.” Police officials in New York said the law, which diverted most cases of 16- and 17-year-old defendants from adult courts to Family Court or to judges with access to social services and special training, was at the root of the crisis.


