Is New York City's high-earner tax base already eroding?
Core argument: New York City's share of the nation's millionaires has fallen 30% since 2010, while Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley expand in Dallas and Atlanta and the financial industry's employment share shrinks.
What the Mamdani coalition has failed to reckon with is that Gotham’s slide towards socialism lite has not been without consequences. The financial industry’s employment share has slowly shrunk as firms like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley hedge their bets by expanding their footprint in Dallas and Atlanta. New York’s share of the nation’s millionaires has declined by 30% since 2010. Mamdani’s tax plan, if enacted, would leave the remainder paying 60% of the city’s taxes. There are, to be sure, diehard affluent New Yorkers who will pay any price and bear any burden to live in the tonier precincts of the five boroughs. There are others who will join the ongoing outmigration of hundreds of thousands of working- and middle-class New Yorkers who’ve left in recent years. Then, of course, one needs to consider the ambitious young professionals who might have moved to New York City in the Bloomberg era, but who’d never dream of it now. Gotham has adapted to the erosion of its economic base through a combination of regulation and subsidy. Virtually all the net job growth in the city in 2023 can be traced to the hiring of home health aides - a “racket,” in the words of Governor Kathy Hochul, underwritten by tens of billions in federal Medicaid spending.


