Are large tax increases the only way to stop rising debt?
Core argument: US governments at all levels collect about 28% of GDP in tax revenue, according to 2022 OECD data, compared with 35% in the United Kingdom, 41% in Sweden, 43% in Italy, and 46% in France.
There is no end in sight to increasing US indebtedness. There are five ways to stop this upward trajectory: (1) extraordinary economic growth, (2) government default, (3) large-scale money creation, (4) substantial cuts in government spending, and (5) large tax increases. Each of the first four ways out of this problem seems either implausible or unacceptable. The US is now a low-tax country compared with its peers. According to OECD data (for 2022), governments at all levels in the US collect only about 28% of GDP in tax revenue, compared with 35% in the United Kingdom, 41% in Sweden, 43% in Italy, and 46% in France. To close a fiscal gap of roughly 4% of GDP with only increased tax revenue, the US would need to raise overall tax revenue by about 14%. If a sizable tax increase is inevitable, we must look beyond the top 1% of the income distribution…closing the fiscal gap will require broadly shared sacrifice. Most nations have value-added taxes, and these taxes have shown themselves to be remarkably efficient. [Across advanced countries], VAT revenues average about 7% of GDP, which is more than enough to close the US fiscal gap.

