Does one state's falling home prices signal a national decline?
Core argument: Florida home prices stand 3% below their May 2024 peak and are falling 3% y/y, the fastest rate among the handful of states where prices are still declining.
Home prices in Florida are now 3% below the peak they reached in May 2024. This in itself is not particularly meaningful. About half of the states are now below their recent peaks. What does make Florida uniquely worrying is that—while most states that have fallen below their peaks are now recovering, with prices rising y/y—prices in Florida continue to decline and by much more than everywhere else. In only a handful of states are home prices falling y/y. In Florida they’re falling at the fastest rate (-3%). Our sense is that the factors responsible for the downturn in Florida [rising new supply, higher insurance costs, and weakening demand] are sufficiently idiosyncratic that it's more likely than not that the price pressures we see there are not a sign of what's to come for the rest of the country. But it’s a close call.

