Has government spending shifted from public services to entitlements?
Core argument: U.S. state spending on public services fell from an estimated 25% of GDP in the early 1950s to about 15% today, while entitlements spending rose from roughly 3% of GDP to about 15%.
America shows how one government became a Lumbering Leviathan. In the early 1950s, we estimate that state spending on public services, including everything from paying teachers’ salaries to building hospitals, equaled 25% of the country’s GDP. At the same time, entitlements spending, broadly defined, was a small line item, with outlays on both pensions and other sorts of welfare equivalent to about 3% of GDP. Today the situation is very different. The American government’s outlays on entitlements have swelled and spending on public services has crashed. Both now equal around 15% of GDP. Governments have accumulated mind-boggling off-balance-sheet obligations to dole out money in the future. We estimate that America’s federal government has made pledges of compensation to different groups worth, in aggregate, six times American GDP


