The Stock Market-Real Economy "Disconnect": A Closer Look
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
US corporate dividend futures for the next 5 years remain significantly below pre-pandemic levels, indicating a bearish outlook for near-term economic conditions.

Andrew Chen, Markus Ibert and Francisco Vazquez-Grande, "The Stock Market-Real Economy "Disconnect": A Closer Look," Federal Reserve Board, October 14, https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/the-stock-market-real-economy-disconnect-a-closer-look-20201014.htm
They also adjust for tech, “….They also adjust for Figure 3 divides the S&P 500 stocks into information technology plus FAANG (Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix, and Google)stocks versus ex-info tech and ex-FAANG stocks. The figure mirrors the previous results: Info tech and FAANG firms, which are expected to pay the lion's share of their dividends at distant dates, have recovered all of their losses and more between March and April. The portfolio of remaining stocks, which is more closely tied to the near and medium term, is still below its pre-pandemic level on September 1….”
Research from Fed decompresses equity prices into short and long term duration assets and finds that dividend future prices are depressed at a five year horizon both in US and overseas. Suggesting the recovery in equity prices btw March and September has been driven by far-dated dividend claims and Mr. Market is still bearish on the near term (<5 years out) outlook. “….S&P 500 dividend futures are contracts that require two parties to exchange, on a specific future date, the dividends that the S&P 500 index paid over the year preceding that date and a predetermined cash amount (the futures price). We use these contracts to create portfolios that decompose the S&P 500 index into the value of S&P 500 dividends that will be paid over different time periods. The market prices of these portfolios are shown in Figure 1…we construct assets that are more comparable to near and medium term economic conditions using data on domestic and international dividend futures and the cross section of U.S. stock returns. We find that the disconnect is driven by gains in the market value of long-term (beyond five years) dividends. In contrast, the value of corporate dividends for the next five years remains far below pre-pandemic levels…our results from dividend futures prices suggest a more pessimistic near and medium term outlook (up to 5 years) compared with the relatively quick recovery in earnings implied by Wall Street analysts' earnings forecasts…”


