Trade Surplus Or Deficit? Neither Matters For Manufacturing Employment Shares
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
Trade surplus countries still see manufacturing employment share decline.
New Robert Lawrence, even countries with large trade surpluses in manufacturing have seen manufacturing employment share decline:
“…Using data from a sample of 60 countries, this paper shows that between 1995 and 2011,on average countries with trade surpluses in manufacturing experienced declines in manufacturing employment shares that were slightly larger than the declines in countries with manufacturing trade deficits. Additionally, the declines in manufacturing employment shares were as large in countries where the manufacturing trade balance moved in a positive direction as in those where it declined. This suggests that even if industrial policies generate larger trade surpluses in manufacturing, they may not succeed in reversing the trend declines in manufacturing employment shares that have persisted in many countries for several decades…”
Robert Lawrence, “Trade Surplus Or Deficit? Neither Matters For Manufacturing Employment Shares,” Peterson Institute For International Economics, September 2020, https://www.piie.com/publications/working-papers/trade-surplus-or-deficit-neither-matters-manufacturing-employment-shares
“….Surplus versus Deficit Countries. In the sample reported in table A1, 26 countries had trade surpluses in manufacturing value added that averaged 3.4 percent of GDP and 34 had deficits that averaged −3.2 percent of GDP (see table 1). The share of MVAin overall spending averaged about 18 percent of GDP. The shares of GDP in manufacturing output, however, were very different:On average the surplus countries produced 21.9 percent of their GDP in manufacturing and the deficit countries just 15.2 percent. While the average manufacturing employment share of 18.1 percent in surplus countries was higher than the 14.8 percent in deficit countries, the difference was much smaller than the difference in value added production shares…..”
Snapshot of the Surplus versus Deficit countries
“…. Countries with trade surpluses in manufacturing have larger shares of manufacturing output in GDP and, although less than proportional to their output shares, relatively higher employment shares in manufacturing.But their surpluses did not prevent declines in their shares of manufacturing employment, declines that were as large as in countries with trade deficits. On balance, even though their relatively faster productivity growth in manufacturing tended to boost their trade surpluses, it also reduced their domestic spending on manufacturing value added and the manufacturing employment shares associated with given shares of domestic spending and net MVA exports….”
However those trade surplus countries are able to maintain manufacturing output as a larger share of GDP:


