Does counting value-added taxes as trade barriers raise reciprocal tariff rates?
Core argument: Trump ordered US economic officials to calculate country-by-country "reciprocal" tariffs based on the total tariffs plus tax, regulatory, currency and other barriers facing US exports, with reports due by April 1 examining first the economies where the US has the largest trade deficits.
Trump on Thursday ordered top economic officials to calculate new US tariffs based on the total tariffs and tax, regulatory, currency and any other barriers that US exports face. The new “reciprocal” duties would be calculated country by country. They will be laid out in a series of reports due by April 1 that officials said would first examine the economies with which the US has the largest trade deficits. Trump and his advisers argue [that] the ability to claim a VAT rebate when products are exported gives European companies an unfair advantage as imports from the US are charged VAT of 15-20% or higher depending on the member country. “Defining a VAT to be a trade barrier isn’t just questionable economics, it also basically forecloses negotiation, as the EU and others aren’t in a fiscal position to negotiate away its tax base,” argues Brad Setser, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. If the US imposes reciprocal tariffs that add VAT rates and MFN tariff rates together, the countries most hit would be India with a rate of 29%, Brazil and the EU.

