Does a low excess earnings yield signal poor stock returns ahead?
Core argument: Shiller's excess CAPE yield stood at 1.4% in July 2026, far below its long-run average of 4.7%, a level indicating stocks are expensive relative to inflation-adjusted Treasury yields.
[Shiller's] "excess Cape yield” measures the difference between the inverted Cape ratio — or cyclically adjusted aggregate earnings per share — and inflation-adjusted yields on Treasury bonds. When stocks are expensive, the excess yield is low. When stocks are cheap, the excess yield is high. Crucially, when the excess yield is low, the subsequent 10-year excess returns on stocks have normally been poor. The excess yield is a mere 1.4% in July 2026, far below its long-run average of 4.7%. With stocks this expensive, the chances of healthy future returns must, again, be relatively low. Cape is far from a perfect predictor of an imminent crash: if it were, it would not be; well-informed investors would then not allow markets to reach extreme positions in the first place, and so crashes would be far less likely.

