How Estimates of the Gig Economy Went Wrong
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
The gig economy’s rise was overstated, with nontraditional jobs increasing by only 1-2% points over the last decade, not 5% as previously estimated, according to @joshzumbrun @WSJ.
WSJ reports on the BLS study on the "Gig Economy" we looked at last summer and previews a forthcoming Krueger/Katz paper confirming the findings
".... “After sifting through the new evidence,” Mr. Krueger said, “Larry Katz and I now conclude that there was a modest rise in the share of the workforce in nontraditional jobs over the last decade—probably on the order of one to 2 percentage points, instead of the five percentage point rise we originally reported.”Comparisons between 2005 and 2015 had a hard time accounting for the difference in economic health. In 2005, wages and overall gross domestic product were growing around 3% a year—the housing bubble meant this growth would be fleeting—and about 63% of U.S. adults had jobs. The housing bust and recession that began in 2007 wrecked all of that, and by 2015, the economy had been on a slow mend. Wages and GDP growth were stagnant at 2%, and employment as a share of the population was about 4 percentage points lower. This created a fertile environment for people to experiment with gig work. Butit didn’t represent a permanent shift, as the Labor Department’s 2017 survey made clear Messrs. Krueger and Katz also conclude surveys of the topic have flaws.By studying individual survey responses, they found that when people answer questions about their spouses, they are much less likely to mention secondary jobs than when they answer questions about themselves. Their own survey hadn’t asked additional questions about spouses, whereas the Labor Department does, leading to a significant discrepancy. “These factors distorted our initial comparison, and highlight the importance of using consistent methods to measure labor force trends over time,” Mr. Katz said...."
Josh Zumbrun, "How Estimates of the Gig Economy Went Wrong,"Wall Street Journal, January 7, 2019, https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-estimates-of-the-gig-economy-went-wrong-11546857000


