Are rising disaster costs straining U.S. property insurance markets?
Core argument: U.S. home insurers took $15.2 billion in net losses in 2023, their worst performance since at least 2000, and are responding by raising premiums and withdrawing coverage.
2023 saw U.S. home insurers take $15.2 billion in net losses, the worst performance since at least 2000. In response, insurers are raising premiums and withdrawing coverage and property insurance markets are looking increasingly shaky in states across the U.S. A sudden withdrawal of insurers from underwriting windstorm, hail, and wildfire risks - similar to the withdrawal from flood insurance that occurred in the early 20th century - is certainly possible. States affected by insurance withdrawals have typically established “last-resort” public plans for properties unable to find a policy in the private market. The rapid growth in these plans, which are ultimately backed by all policy-holders or taxpayers in a state, is a clear signal of growing unavailability of private insurance: total underwriting by public plans reached a new record high in 2023 at just over $1.3 trillion in exposure; Florida, California, and Louisiana all saw their plans more than quadruple in the five years from 2018 to 2023.

