Did excluding Chinese immigrants reduce white labor supply and manufacturing output?
Core argument: Counties with higher Chinese population shares on the eve of the 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act show increasingly negative estimated effects on white and total labor supply after the Act, with coefficients at zero beforehand.
The 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act barred all China-born “laborers” from entering the United States and all individuals of Chinese ethnicity from naturalization for ten years. [It] was renewed for ten more years in 1892, made indefinite in 1902 [and] repealed in 1943. We exploit two sources of variation: time variation in the introduction of the Act and cross-sectional variation ina county’s Chinese population share on the eve of the Act. The latter influences the intensity of treatment: counties with a higher Chinese population share will be more affected by the Act than counties with fewer Chinese immigrants. To understand the evolution of the effects, we estimate a dynamic specification. Figure 3a presents the estimates for the labor supply of Chinese, white and all races. For white and all labor, the coefficients are zero prior to the Act and become increasingly negative afterwards. The timing of the trend break coincides with the Act. Figure 3c plots the estimates for total manufacturing output and the number of establishments. The negative effects on manufacturing trail the negative effects on labor. We find no evidence of pre-trends.

