How much would closing the trade deficit raise manufacturing employment?
Core argument: Eliminating the US manufacturing trade deficit by shifting purchases from foreign to domestic goods would raise manufacturing's share of total US employment by 1.7 percentage points, from 7.9% to 9.7%.
In 2024, total US value added in manufacturing was $2.913 trillion. Thus, the manufacturing value added in the trade deficit equaled 21.5% of US production. Had Americans maintained the same level of spending but met their demand with additional domestic production rather than through imports, manufacturing production would have been 21.5% larger. Even if the tariffs and other trade policies eliminate the US manufacturing trade deficit by switching US purchases from foreign to domestic goods, the share of manufacturing employment in total US employment would increase by just 1.7 percentage points, from 7.9 to 9.7%, and the share of workers in production occupations in US manufacturing would increase by just under 0.9 percentage point, from 3.85 to 4.7%. These results point to the dangers of exaggerating the gains that policies directed at closing the trade deficit are likely to induce. The US manufacturing trade deficit of $1.2 trillion is a large number, but it is a relatively small share of an economy with a GDP of $29.1 trillion in 2024. The changes in employment with balanced trade would be far too small to produce a labor market that significantly increases the opportunities for men without college degrees.

