Is the US border enforceable?
Core argument: Monthly border encounters since 2011 show the immigration wave under President Biden was unprecedented, with the chart marking the start of each administration back to President Obama.
The chart shows monthly [border] encounters back to 2011. It marks the start of every new administration back to President Obama. The immigration wave under President Biden was unprecedented. Some of this reflects pent-up demand, since the COVID pandemic sharply reduced immigration that had been on a rising track in the first Trump administration. Immigration has gone to near zero from February 2025, which the second Trump administration has achieved by leaning on Mexico (including by threatening tariffs). No matter which side of the immigration debate you’re on, this shows that the border is enforceable. The immigration wave under President Biden collided with a segmented labor market that - while it was healthy on the surface - was leaving more and more people on the sidelines.

