How wide is the plausible range of US net migration?
Core argument: The authors' "low" immigration scenario, set at roughly the 20th percentile of plausible net flows, projects U.S. net migration of -650,000 in 2025, meaning more people leaving the country than entering.
We think of the scenarios as spanning the range of plausible policy actions, something like the 20th percentile of resulting net flows (“low”) to the 80th percentile (“high”). In the first two years of the “low” scenario, in which we anticipate the most acute departure from recent policy, we expect the United States to see net outmigration—that is, the extraordinary case of more people leaving the country than entering. Under this scenario, in 2025 migration would be -650,000. The “high” scenario assumes immigration policy is only modestly more aggressive than it was in the first Trump administration. The resulting immigration flows would be positive 1.3 million in 2025. To be sure, immigration flows could be outside the range of our scenarios. During the campaign, Trump called for immediate mass deportations more than 10 times what we incorporate even in our “low” scenario.

