Is the economy's post-pandemic outperformance driven by immigration rather than technology?
Core argument: U.S. economic output has exceeded pre-pandemic forecasts since Covid, but that outperformance is attributed mostly to an unexpected surge in immigration rather than to new technology.
If you weren't paying attention, you might have thought that with all of this new technology — the U.S. economy has definitely outperformed post-Covid, we're above pre-pandemic forecasts, which is really amazing — but if you start to look into it, it's mostly because of an unexpected surge in immigration. And so with the technological stuff, we really don't know. Back in the 60s, there was all this futurism. There were people making long-run projections, and Herman Kahn had this thing called the Year 2000, which was about what the world would look like in this far distant year of 2000. There were like a hundred predicted innovations, and he got almost all of the ones that actually did happen. There’s stuff in there that is recognizably smartphones. There are things that recognizably are pretty much all of the sexy technologies that have come along since the 1960s. There's also like 60 technologies he predicted that didn't come to pass. We have a much more pokey backwards world than what people in the 1960s thought we were going to be even 10 or 15 years ago.


