How much would eliminating the trade deficit restore manufacturing's share?
Core argument: The U.S. manufactures trade deficit ran about 4% of GDP last year, and a rough estimate suggests eliminating it entirely would raise manufacturing value-added by roughly 2.5 percentage points from 10% of GDP, since manufacturers buy many services.
Last year the U.S. ran a manufactures trade deficit of around 4% of GDP. Suppose we assume that this deficit subtracted an equal amount from spending on U.S. manufactured goods. In that case what would happen if we somehow eliminated that deficit? Well, it would raise the share of manufacturing in GDP — currently 10%— by less than 4 percentage points, because manufacturing firms buy a lot of services. A rough estimate is that manufacturing value-added would rise by around 60% of the change in sales, or 2.5 percentage points, implying that the manufacturing sector would be around a quarter larger than it is. Manufacturing as a share of employment has fallen about 17 points since 1970. Complete elimination of the trade deficit would undo only around 2.5 points of that decline. So even if tariffs “worked,” which they won’t, they would fall far short of restoring manufacturing to its former glory. [Likewise, even] Germany’s huge trade surpluses haven’t been enough to avoid a big shift away from manufacturing,

