Quantifying the commodity consumer shock at 5-6 of global GDP its as big as the early 1970s
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
Ongoing commodity shock is on track to be a similar order of magnitude as the first oil shock in terms of share of global GDP. US commodities consumers will pay ~ $1T more relative to 2019 or -3.4% of US GDP.
Ephrem Ravi and Krishan M Agarwal, "Quantifying the commodity consumer shock - at ~5-6% of global GDP it’s as big as the early 1970’s,"Citi, June 14, 2022, https://www.citi.com/mss/solutions/citi-research/
Global consumers of commodities are set to pay producers ~$5.2tr more during 2022 than they did in 2019, an increase representing ~5.0% of world GDP, using Citi’s base case 2H’22 forecasts. In the scenario that 2H’22 forward prices materialise, the commodity ‘tax’ paid by consumers would be ~$6.3tr higher than during 2019, equal to ~6.2% of GDP. In either case, the ongoing commodity shock is on track to be a similar order of magnitude as the first oil shock almost 50 years ago, when taken as a share of global GDP.The longer the commodity shock persists, the bigger the negative impact on commodity consumers and on net, global growth and equities. We find that Europe and some EMs growth looks particularly vulnerable, as does € credit, to a higher for longer commodity price scenario, while South American FX should benefit. For OECD Europe, consumers of commodities could pay $1.4tr more during 2022 than they did in 2019, with commodity consumption costs rising to $2.3tr from $0.9tr, representing an increase of -5.9% of OECD Europe GDP, comparing May spot (annualised, to 2019, or using 2H'22 forwards). The value of commodities consumed in Europe is estimated to have been higher during May 2022 (annualised), at 10.3% of GDP, than it was during the peak of the 2000's commodity supercycle period, at 8.2% of GDP.Europe is a major net energy importer. For the US. consumers of commodities could pay $1.0tr more during 2022 than they did in 2019, with commodity consumption costs rising to $1.8tr from $.8tr representing an increase of -3.4% of US GDP, comparing May spot (annualised to 2019)The US is a net energy and agricultural commodity exporter.



Anand Comment:the difference has to be net energy? And, the US could be a much larger net energy exporter if we had the right policies….if we don’t drill, someone else will. Nowhere is this more true than natural gas where the qataris make billions while we ban drilling/fracking in the marcellus (especially NY)
Steve Comment:Yes I think you are largely correct plus one other factor - suspect differences btw our (US versus Europe) corporate sectors both in level of intangible investment btw comps and the size of our relative sectors, ie the mittelstand is a larger share of the German corporate sector than in the US (manufacturing is 18% of value added in 2020 in Germany versus 11% in the US the previous year according to World Bank.)