Why has AI not yet appeared in macroeconomic data?
Core argument: Three years after ChatGPT's release, AI is absent from employment, productivity and inflation data, and shows no signs in profit margins or earnings expectations for the S&P 493, echoing Robert Solow's 1987 productivity paradox.
The Nobel Prize–winning economist Robert Solow said in 1987, “You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics.” This observation is the so‑called Solow productivity paradox. The same can be said today: AI is everywhere except in the incoming macroeconomic data. Today, you don’t see AI in the employment data, productivity data or inflation data. Similarly, for the S&P 493, there are no signs of AI in profit margins or earnings expectations. Maybe there is a J‑curve effect for AI, where it takes time for AI to show up in the macro data. Maybe not. Whether there is a J-curve effect depends on the value creation from AI. There is fierce competition between the builders of large language models (LLMs), which is driving the price of LLMs toward zero for end-users. From a macro perspective, the value creation is not the product, but how generative AI is used and implemented in different sectors in the economy. The academic literature is still inconclusive about the potential macro effects of AI [see table in gallery]. The [disparate and inconclusive results in the table suggest that] after three years with ChatGPT and still no signs of AI in the incoming data, AI will likely be labor-enhancing in some sectors rather than labor-replacing in all sectors.

