Do tariffs act as a corporate tax hike markets haven't priced?
Core argument: The U.S. aggregate effective tariff rate stood at 3% before April, making Trump's tariffs a sizable increase equivalent to a sudden corporate tax hike that in aggregate would run into the hundreds of billions of dollars.
Trump’s tariffs are equivalent to a sudden corporate tax hike that in aggregate would be in the hundreds of billions. In theory, the impact on tariffs can be blunted by a strengthening currency and substitution towards non-tariffed countries. However, the dollar has been weakening and a global minimum tariff makes substitution less likely as it impacts all imports regardless of origin. This suggests that the importing company will bear the brunt of the tariffs through higher import costs and lower sales volumes. The U.S. aggregate effective tariff rate was just 3% before April, so the new tariffs are a sizable increase. The negative impact of tariffs on companies is potentially a sizable hit on profits, but more importantly an unknowably negative impact on profits. Many companies will not know how their costs will be impacted by tariffs until after an extended negotiation period. They will also not know how much of the increase they will be able to pass on to their consumers. This impact does not appear to be factored into forward earnings, which remain elevated. Earnings are just one input into stock prices and are sometimes not even very important, but the clear negative profit impact of tariffs does not seem to be in the price.

