Does a city depend on its wealthiest residents for revenue?
Core argument: In 2017, 1,818 New York City families earning over $10m each paid $2.8bn in local income taxes, nearly 25% of the city's total income tax revenue.
In 2017, 1,818 families in NYC earned over $10m each and contributed $2.8bn in local income taxes, nearly 25% of the total income tax revenue. This small group of high earners plays a crucial role in the city's fiscal health, as they collectively paid $6.1bn in income taxes, accounting for 53% of local income taxes. If this trend continued, they likely contributed $6.7bn for the recent fiscal year, over 10% of NYC's total tax collections. The absence of these contributions would necessitate explaining to middle-class residents why services like trash collection are reduced, to poorer residents why crime control is lacking, and to public-sector workers why early retirement is no longer feasible. Beyond taxes, wealthy individuals support cultural institutions through donations, enhancing NYC's appeal and attracting tourists and residents, thereby strengthening the tax base. Their presence is vital for maintaining the city's livability and economic stability.



Ed Comment:Unfortunately, this is only income tax not property or sales tax which are probably a large share of taxes and regressive.
“…In 2017 (the last year for which full data is available),65,053 New York households — about 1.7 percent of tax filers — made above half a million dollars, according to the city’s Independent Budget Office. They paid a whopping $6.1 billion in income taxes to the city, or 53 percent of local income taxes….The richest of the rich?In 2017, 1,818 families earned above $10 million each — and paid $2.8 billion in local income taxes, or nearly a quarter of total income taxes….”