How did Democratic Senate candidates win states the presidential nominee flipped?
Core argument: Four Democratic senators won in states Trump flipped from blue to red, an outcome that defies recent history in which the party flipping a presidential state almost always wins the concurrent Senate race.
Four Democrats won in states that Trump flipped from blue to red. Such a feat defies recent political history. When a presidential candidate flips a state, their party almost always wins the concurrent Senate race; e.g. Democrats won all Senate races in states that Biden flipped blue in 2020. Republicans did the same in 2016. In fact, between 2004 and 2020 such split outcomes have happened just twice—Democrat Joe Donnelly’s 2012 win in Indiana and Republican Judd Gregg’s 2004 victory in New Hampshire. How did Democrats eke out Senate wins in states that Trump flipped? Each certainly benefited from ticket-splitting. But Democratic success may also owe to the traditional “undervote”—voters who selected Trump and left the rest of their ballot blank. Others, meanwhile, voted for a minor third-party Senate candidate, effectively the same as an undervote. The undervote, of course, is difficult to disentangle from persuasion effects. What share of Trump-only voters will show up in the midterms? Can the GOP retain their first-time non-white voters? Realignment—or not—hangs in the balance.

