Have economists overstated their ability to control economic outcomes?
Core argument: The business cycle remains unconquered despite a half-century of efforts to manage growth and stability through interest rates, taxes, and government spending, with the 2007–2009 Great Recession offered as evidence that economists overstated their control over economic outcomes.
The economic landscape over the past half-century has been marked by the rise and fall of macroeconomic strategies, with economists often overstating their ability to control economic outcomes. Despite attempts to regulate growth and stability through interest rates, taxes, and government spending, the business cycle remains unconquered, as evidenced by events like the 2007-2009 Great Recession. This persistence is partly due to the difficulty people have in changing their minds once set, making them resistant to new arguments or evidence. This resistance is compounded by the tendency of modern democracies to avoid present sacrifices for future gains, as seen in issues like rising Social Security and Medicare costs and the lack of consensus on addressing climate change. These challenges highlight the limitations of economic policies and the need for new approaches to tackle 21st-century problems.



Ed Comment:“…I agree with most of this, and surely the part that people are utterly unpersuadable (I can hear Steve smugly claiming that I once persuaded him about the financial crisis, and it’s true. But it doesn’t change my view.) Worse, I believe the world is intentionally coated in a thick coating of lies, largely liberal lies. It seems to be that we have sort of tamed unnecessary business downturns. We don’t inflate as if it will produce growth in the long run. And we haven’t intentionally caused a rescissions since Volker stupidly and unnecessarily slammed on the brakes and sent the economy through the windshield. Greenspan largely had it right. The recession we have seen (since Volker) have largely come from non-economic shocks. Covid and terrorists for example. Arguably the financial crisis was avoidable. But I think it was near-impossible to see that large trade deficits destabilized an inherently unstable banking systems. And that would lead to a run on the banks. Perhaps we reduced the risk of that but only by suffering the slowest recovery since the great depression. The real macro economic problem is that we discover risk like covid that then require a reallocation of resources, e.g. from restaurants to jobs for skilled workers we haven’t dreamed up/created. Similarly, the financial crisis required reallocating risk-averse savings away from subprime consumption via subprime home equity loans. Reengineering new allocations can take a long time.…”
Robert J. Samuelson, "Goodbye, readers, and good luck — you’ll need it,"