Reconciliation Bill Tax Proposal In Context
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
@JasonFurman Reconciliation bill is a small change in the overall level of taxation but a large change in composition, raising revenue by 0.5% of GDP, shifting tax burden to high-income earners & increasing corporate taxes to pre-TCJA levels.
Jason Furman tries to put the reconciliation bills moving tax proposal in context, "The reconciliation bill is a small change in the overall level of taxation but a large change in the composition of taxation. A brief putting this in context. (Note for this thread "reconciliation bill" = House Ways & Means version, will likely change somewhat.)The reconciliation bill would raise revenue by about 1/2 percent of GDP annually. That is expected to bring revenue to ~18% of GDP. That is well within the historical range and well below previous peaks during periods of low unemployment rates like the one CBO is forecasting. The bill has large gross changes ($2.1T in raisers & $1.2T in costers) for a much smaller net increase: High-income & misc increases: $1.1T Corporate increases: $1.0T Infrastructure & community development: -$0.1T Green energy: -$0.2T Children/safety net: -$0.8T NET: $0.9T. The last tweet was the total budget impact of the tax title as scored by JCT. A lot of the gross costers are scored as spending increases not tax cuts (e.g., a low-income parent that gets a child allowance). So while the bill raises $0.9T it actually raises taxes by $1.6T. (How these grosses, nets and revenue classifications get counted towards whatever the allowable gross number of $1.5T or $2T or $3.5T will matter a lot in terms of how much fits within the agreed upon window.)Total taxes are not up very much & well within historical range. But the way they are collected is very different--including the highest tax rate on the top 1% since the late 1970s & the ~lowest tax rate on just about everyone else (ignore the freakishly low pandemic yrs). This evolution reflects the ratchet we're in for the bottom 99% (both parties cut their taxes when in power) and the cycle at the top (Republicans lower them and Democrats raise them). Note the bottom quintile would have negative taxes for the first time (not counting pandemic).Corporate taxes are also changing. The bill, on net, undoes the 2017 TCJA corporate rate reductions and so results in corporate taxes roughly where they would have been absent that legislation but with lower rates and more spending on green stuff. These changes are all mostly in the right direction my my perspective but mostly wanted you to have the information to make your own judgment."
Jason Furman, “Reconciliation Bill Tax Proposal In Context,” @jasonfurman, October 7, 2021, https://twitter.com/jasonfurman/status/1446130388024373248


