Does China's true manufacturing surplus remain larger than official figures suggest?
Core argument: China's manufacturing goods surplus, stripped of gold and semiconductor imports, continues to rise, with the underlying goods surplus approaching 7% of GDP — an exceptionally large external imbalance for an economy of China's scale.
The easiest way to see what is happening is just to focus on the manufacturing surplus without gold and chips. It keeps on rising. In fact, without the 1.5 pp of GDP in gold imports in q2, the goods surplus would be close to 7% of GDP -- an absolutely massive number for an economy as big as China.

