Removing Barriers to Accessing High-Productivity Places
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
Internal US migration has significantly decreased, with a notable decline in people moving for new jobs. This trend is not due to demographics but rather a breakdown in traditional migration patterns, as shown by @DanielShoag.
as requested looked at the Shoag paper you fwd for data on the migration patterns of native born middle class (note Shoag was co-author of the NEBR paper that showed income across states converge @ ~ 2% a year until 1990, this is based off of that, no new data)
"...Molloy, Smith, and Wozniak (2014), as well as Kaplan and Schulhofer-Wohl (2017), showed that internal U.S. migration has decreased significantly. They further showed that this decline cannot be explained by demographics, and that the largest component was a decline in the number of people moving for new jobs. Dao, Furceri, and Loungani (2017) demonstrated that mobility is less responsive to labor demand conditions than it was in the past. Ganong and Shoag (2017) also show that migration to the richer, more productive parts of the country has virtually ceased. Poor places are no longer catching up to rich ones, and people are no longer moving from poor places to rich ones. The traditional ways in which American society has ameliorated large gaps between places have broken down...In 1960 it made sense for both lawyers and janitors to move from the Deep South to the New York area, because both groups earned significantly higher wages even adjusting for housing costs (Ganong and Shoag 2017). Today, even though both groups earn higher wages in the New York metropolitan area, it no longer makes sense for janitors to move. Lawyers still earn more net of housing costs in the New York area, but the enormous housing costs mean that janitors’ wages net of housing costs are actually lower in the New York area than they are in the Deep South..."
However note that finding was based on PUMA's while it's granular it doesn't adjust for commuting from say the outer boroughs to Manhattan. You found it unconvincing
Daniel Shoag, "Removing Barriers to Accessing High-Productivity Places," Brookings Institution, January 31, 2019, https://www.hamiltonproject.org/papers/removing_barriers_to_accessing_high_productivity_places


