Core argument: Hourly earnings in 41 immigrant-dependent industries rose 3.5% year-over-year in February, underperforming the 3.8% gain for all workers, suggesting immigration.
The analysis used 2024 census data to identify fields—including construction, restaurants, food manufacturing and hotels—that rely heavily on noncitizens with a high-school degree or less, a common proxy for people who entered the country illegally. The Journal excluded industries such as agriculture and the gig economy, for which the Labor Department doesn’t publish hourly earnings. The result: Across 41 industries that rely most heavily on low-skilled immigrants, hourly earnings rose by a weighted average of 3.5% in February from a year earlier, according to the latest figures. That was less than the 3.8% increase in average hourly earnings for all workers and marked a slowdown from before Trump took office. Employment in those 41 immigrant-dependent industries fell by 90,400 in February from a year earlier, while overall employment grew by 298,000 jobs in the same stretch. Preliminary March figures available for 23 of the sectors show a year-over-year gain of 39,400 jobs, boosted by hiring in construction and food service.What Everyone Got Wrong About Jobs and the Immigration Crackdown
AI Summary. Industries most dependent on low-skilled immigrant workers saw wages rise 3.5% and employment fall by 90,400, both underperforming the broader economy, where wages grew 3.8% and total employment rose by 298,000.
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
- Is Important:
- Important
Industries most dependent on low-skilled immigrant workers saw wages rise 3.5% and employment fall by 90,400 Y/Y in Feb, underperforming the broader economy, where wages grew 3.8% and total employment rose by 298,000.
Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI
- Hourly earnings in 41 immigrant-dependent industries rose 3.5% year-over-year in February, underperforming the 3.8% gain for all workers, suggesting immigration.
- Employment in immigrant-reliant industries fell 90,400 in February versus a year earlier while overall employment grew 298,000, indicating labor supply.
- March preliminary data showed 39,400 jobs added across 23 immigrant-dependent sectors year-over-year, reversing February’s decline and suggesting seasonal hiring in.


