Does low-skilled immigration leave the labor market more vulnerable to downturns?
Core argument: Research suggests the great majority of illegal immigrants in the U.S. have no more than a high school education, concentrating recent migration among lower-skilled workers, who face higher unemployment rates and greater sensitivity to economic conditions.
The lower-skilled nature of recent U.S. migrants makes the U.S. labor market particularly vulnerable to economic weakness. Unlike other countries, the recent surge in migration into the U.S. has largely been through illegal channels so the exact number is unknown. The migrants bypass the skills-based legal filters typical in other countries and tend to be lower-skilled. Research suggests that the great majority of illegal immigrants have no more than a high school education. They also predominantly originate from non-English speaking countries and so tend to have low levels of English proficiency. Lower-skilled laborers have higher unemployment rates and are also more sensitive to economic conditions. The experience abroad suggests that newer migrants have more difficulty with the labor market and that difficulty would be compounded by lower skill levels.

