Does import competition raise productivity only at low-productivity family-managed firms?
Core argument: Firm-level Spanish data for 1993–2007 show that initially low-productivity family-managed firms raised productivity significantly after EU import tariff reductions, while initially productive family firms and non-family firms showed no productivity response to import competition.
Analysis of firm-level data from Spain between 1993-2007 reveals that low productivity family-managed firms significantly increased productivity following reductions in EU-imposed import tariffs. This contrasts with initially productive family firms and non-family firms, whose productivity remained unaffected by import competition. The productivity gains in family-managed firms were attributed to more efficient use of input materials rather than innovation activities like R&D. The increased bankruptcy risk from import competition motivated family managers to enhance cash flow for survival, a behavior more pronounced in multigenerational family firms. These findings highlight the unique response of family managers to import shocks, challenging the notion that they are less productive and suggesting a focus on short-term efficiency over long-term innovation.


