Does counting taxes and transfers shrink measured US income inequality?
Core argument: Gramm and Early estimate the real income differential between the top and bottom U.S. quintiles is about 4:1, not the widely assumed 60:1, once taxes and in-kind transfers are counted.
Contrary to popular belief, the real income differential between the top and bottom quintiles in the U.S. is about 4:1, not the widely assumed 60:1. This finding by Gramm and Early highlights a more equitable income distribution than perceived. Conventional measures often exclude taxes and in-kind transfers, inflating top quintile incomes and underestimating bottom quintile resources. In 2017, after adjusting for taxes and including government transfers, the top quintile had an average after-tax income of $186,000, while the bottom quintile had $47,200 in available resources. The upper fifth pays over 80% of federal income taxes, while the bottom quintile benefits from programs like SNAP and EITC. This analysis challenges the narrative of extreme inequality and suggests that the U.S. income distribution is more balanced, reflecting a free enterprise system where achievement is rewarded.



Jahncke Comment:Good Morning Two weeks ago, the Wall Street Journal published a column (attached) of major importance in this election cycle, in which Democrats have proposed policy changes that would change America fundamentally -- imposing huge tax increases upon high-earners and the wealthy in order to fund massive expansion of social welfare programs, such as Medicare for all. The WSJ column suggested that calls for such fundamental change are based largely upon a distorted picture of income inequality. It showed that income after payment of taxes and receipt of income redistributions is already largely equal, despite widespread belief to the contrary. The column revealed that conventional measures of income inequality omit taxes paid as well as all in-kind benefit tranfers, such as food stamps. These omissions overstate income in upper segments of the population and understate income in the lower segments. I have written “a column about a column,” providing more explanation, detail and historical background about the anomaly of these omissions, after extensive conversation with the co-authors of the WSJ column. Attached Spreadsheet:For those with further interest in income inequality, I’ve attached a spreadsheet I prepared based upon the WSJ column analysis and supplementary data provided by co-author John Early. The first five columns derive the 4 to 1 ratio of income at the top to income at the bottom which Gramm and Early presented in their column. Column (6) shows that government transfers constitute the majority of income in the bottom 40% of the population. The next column (7) shows the amount of the increased transfers and taxes that would be necessary to bring about absolute income equality across 80% of the population via increased taxes on the top 20%, as reflected in column (8). Column (9) shows that the tax rate on the top quintile would have to double to accomplish this - from 36.9% in column (4) to 69.7% in column (9), a massive increase, certain to have significant consequences. Also of consequence would be the negative impact upon society’s work ethic as government transfers grew to a majority of income for over half the population, specifically with transfers growing from 55.5% to 73.0% of total income in the lower-middle quintile and from 26.9% to 45.1% in the middle quintile, as reflected in column (10). As Gramm and Early write in their column, “In 1967, when the funding for the War on Poverty started to flow, almost 70% of prime working-age adults in the bottom quintile households were employed. Over the next 50 years, that share fell to 36%.”Radio Interview:I discussed the WSJ column and declining workforce participation in the lowest quintile onWTIC radio with Todd Feinburg on November 5thColumn (11) shows that the upper quintile would be required to pay approximately $2.4 trillion in additional annual taxes to fund income equality across the other four quintiles. This enormous amount is roughly equivalent to the $2.05 trillion cost that Elizabeth Warren has offered as the cost of her Medicare for all proposal, which she claims would entail no tax increases on the middle class.