Edward Conard

Top Ten New York Times Bestselling Author

  • “…a comprehensive explanation of the modern economy.” - Julian Robertson, Founder, Tiger Management
  • “Unintended Consequences is full of substance, it is one of the must-read books of the year, and once I finish it I will be giving it a second read through right away.” - Tyler Cowen, Professor, George Mason University
  • “…reminds us that inequality sends a signal of what society lacks most, in America’s case, entrepreneurship and risk taking.” - Lawrence Lindsey, CEO, The Lindsey Group, former Director of the National Economic Council
  • “…a must-read for serious students of economic policy.” - Glenn Hubbard, Dean, Columbia Business School, and former Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers
  • “…a fresh argument for the productive value of inequality.” - David Autor, Professor of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
  • “…a very valuable contribution.” - Larry Summers, former Secretary of the Treasury and director of the National Economic Council, president emeritus, Harvard University
  • “…challenges misconceptions that distort our economic debates.” - Arthur Brooks, President of the American Enterprise Institute
  • “…serious thinking for serious thinkers. …a thought-provoking blueprint for growing middle- and working-class incomes.” - Mitt Romney, former Governor of Massachusetts
  • “Unintended Consequences should be read by anyone who takes for granted the superiority of progressive taxation and has not thought carefully about the trade-offs involved.” - The New Republic
  • “A full-throated defense of economic dynamism.” - The Wall Street Journal
  • “…a must-read for serious students of economic policy.” - Glenn Hubbard, Dean, Columbia Business School, and former Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers
  • “…challenges misconceptions that distort our economic debates.” - Arthur Brooks, President of the American Enterprise Institute
Upside of Inequality Oxford Unintended Consequences
Buy the Books
  • Macro Roundup
  • About Roundup
  • About Ed Conard
  • Highlights
  • Topics
  • Subscribe
Edward Conard
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • youtube
  • Email
  • Text Message (SMS)
  • Twitter/X
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • WhatsApp Message
Subscribe to Macro Roundup Emails
  • Mentions 388
  • Primary focus 193
For whatever topics you select (currently: Government Spending):
Choose search scope

Your importance filter 'Database' shows fewer articles.

Remove filters to see full article counts

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is

AI Summary. Compensation makes up over 50% of police operating budgets before benefits and pensions, and multiyear labor contracts and pension obligations make cuts difficult, leaving many reductions superficial or temporary. Local policing spending rose 176% from 1977 to 2017, outpacing the 137% rise in general expenses.

Andrea Fuller Wall Street Journal
Date Posted:
August 13, 2020
Is Database:
Database

Compensation alone constitutes over 50% of police operating budgets, excluding benefits and pension costs, making it hard for cities to cut police budgets @AndreaFuller @WSJ.

Why is cutting police budgets so difficult for cities?

Core argument: Compensation alone accounts for over 50% of police operating budgets, excluding benefits and pension costs.

Cities are grappling with the challenge of cutting police budgets, as compensation alone constitutes over 50% of police operating budgets, excluding benefits and pension costs. Despite public pressure to defund, many cuts are superficial or temporary, with some cities like San Diego even increasing police budgets. From 1977 to 2017, local spending on policing surged 176%, outpacing the 137% rise in general expenses, driven by multiyear labor contracts and pension obligations. Pension costs have tripled in major cities over 18 years, and police misconduct settlements exceeded $1bn from 2010-2014. Efforts to redirect funds to social services face resistance due to entrenched financial commitments and public safety concerns amid rising violent crime rates.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Compensation alone accounts for over 50% of police operating budgets, excluding benefits and pension costs.
  2. Local spending on policing rose 176% from 1977 to 2017, outpacing the 137% increase in general local expenses, driven by multiyear labor contracts and pension obligations.
  3. Pension costs tripled in major cities over 18 years and police misconduct settlements exceeded $1bn from 2010 to 2014, while cities such as San Diego increased police budgets despite public pressure to defund.

Heather Gillers and Andrea Fuller, "Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is,"Wall Street Journal, August 12, 2020, https://www.wsj.com/articles/cities-weigh-cutting-police-budgets-and-discover-how-hard-that-is-11597261079

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is

Cities across America are weighing whether to reduce or redirect spending on police. Some, with backing from mayors and city councils, are already undertaking efforts to do so, as protesters in their streets call for “defunding.”

They’re quickly learning that police budgets, built up over generations with broad public support, are difficult to dismantle.

Elected officials in New York, Seattle, Los Angeles and Minneapolis, among other places, have approved plans to reduce police budgets in response to the nationwide protests following the killing of George Floyd in police custody in Minneapolis.

But many of the cuts are cosmetic, temporary or represent a relatively small part of budgets. In the case of Minneapolis, they may not stick. A Minnesota state commission has delayed a city council plan to put a proposal to disband the police department on the November ballot.

On Monday, Seattle’s city council approved about a $3 million cut to police spending for the remaining budget year, around 1% of the annual police budget but far less than the 50% target some on the city council have proposed. Police Chief Carmen Best, the first Black woman to hold the post and who opposed sharp spending cuts, announced her retirement in the wake of the decision and decried a “lack of respect” for officers.

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is: Extended Excerpt Image 1


Other cities are trying to avoid cutting police funding despite hits to tax revenue from the economic slowdown. A few, such as San Diego, have even voted to increase police budgets recently.

The calls for cutting come amid a rise in violent crime in several large U.S. cities this year, including a murder increase in most large ones. Chicago on Sunday night saw heavy looting of its Magnificent Mile and other upscale shopping districts following a police shooting that wounded a man in another area. Officers said he had fired on them first.

Chicago recorded 94 homicides in the 28 days ended Aug. 2. Speaking before Sunday’s looting, Alderman Matt O’Shea, a Democrat, said, “We just had the most violent month in 28 years. Is now really the time to talk about defunding, whatever that is?”

Even activists differ on what defunding the police means. Some want to outright end or deeply cut police departments. Others say the term means redirecting a portion of police money to things such as social workers, education, and job programs, or moving functions to other departments.

Recent polling suggests Americans support changes in policing, but also broadly support police. In a mid-June poll by Pew Research Center, following the first of the protests after the George Floyd killing, about 42% of Black adults surveyed favored reductions in spending on policing in their areas, and 21% of white adults did.

Gallup polling released more recently found that 47% of all respondents and 70% of Black respondents supported shifting some police spending to social programs. Still, 67% overall and 61% of Black Americans wanted to see the police presence in their neighborhoods remain the same, and about one-fifth of both groups wanted to see it increase.

The polling showed 58% of Americans support major changes to policing, but just 15% support abolishing the police.

“What I know from being in city council and now as mayor is that people don’t necessarily take exception to the presence of police in their communities,” said Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms. “They take exception to bad police in their communities.”

Support from voters and politicians is a reason that local spending on police—now around $100 billion a year—has outpaced the overall growth of city and county budgets over roughly four decades, rising faster than K-12 education, sanitation and parks and recreation, according to a Wall Street Journal analysis of Census data compiled by the Urban Institute think tank. Between 1977 and 2017, local spending on policing rose 176%, versus a 137% rise in general expenses, accounting for inflation.

“In Atlanta when I look at our police budget, I see capital costs, I see salaries, I see pension costs, I see workers’ compensation,” said Ms. Bottoms, a Democrat. One of her first moves as mayor in 2018 was to increase police salaries.

She has also invested city resources in community programs and is pushing to overhaul use-of-force practices. In June, the Atlanta city council narrowly voted down police budget cuts called for by some activists.

“Re-imagining our police department is a conversation that I’m very much interested in having,” Ms. Bottoms said. “Eliminating the police department is a nonstarter of a conversation.”

Some defunding proponents acknowledge that police budgets can’t be quickly or easily dismantled. But they say it is the only way to end law-enforcement tactics they say disproportionately impact minority communities.

Reducing police funding “is going to be a process over time,” said Andrea Ritchie, a researcher at the Barnard Center for Research on Women. She has publicly advocated deep cuts in police spending, saying the money could be better spent addressing the root causes of violence.

Police budgets are set by elected officials at local and state levels, with spending often enshrined in multiyear labor contracts negotiated with unions, and with pension obligations that last for decades. Some police spending is obligated by court settlements over use of force.

Compensation makes up more than half of police department operating budgets, without counting benefit and pension costs, according to a Journal analysis of data from the Census Bureau and a Justice Department unit called the Bureau of Justice Statistics. Cities that pay below-market salaries risk losing officers to neighboring towns.

Agreements with police unions establish work conditions—typically pay, hours and benefits—in 71% of departments that serve a million or more people and in 53% of police departments serving 500,000 to a million people, according to a Bureau of Justice Statistics report from 2013, the most recent. Sometimes, union rules mandate the number of officers on a shift or assignment.

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is: Extended Excerpt Image 2


Police pension-plan costs for 12 major cities and counties tracked by the Boston College Center for Retirement Research average more than three times what they did 18 years ago, adjusted for inflation. Pension obligations, which often kick in when officers are middle-aged and set up many years of payouts, can be decades long.

New York City’s spending on police department pensions has risen 94%, accounting for inflation, since 2005 to $2.8 billion in 2020, according to data collected by the Citizens Budget Commission, a watchdog group. The pension rise was steeper than any other major budget item relating to the police.

Police misconduct creates another set of spending obligations, as departments have faced persistent problems with the use of force. The 10 U.S. cities with the largest police departments paid out more than $1 billion in settlements and judgments from 2010 through 2014, an investigation by the Journal found. Justice Department probes have led to expensive changes such as adding body cameras and capping the numbers of officers per supervisor.

“All of this stuff is really hard to dislodge,” said Michael Leo Owens, an associate professor of political science at Emory University in Atlanta. “If you look at the reforms are mentioning, they’re not talking about serious money.”

Since the killing of Mr. Floyd on May 25, some local elected officials have been more receptive to shifting some police money or finding ways to raise spending on other services. They are pledging more for mental-health counselors in Austin, Texas, and social services in Los Angeles.

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is: Extended Excerpt Image 3


New York Mayor Bill de Blasio in late June announced roughly $1 billion in cuts to the $5.6 billion police operating budget for the fiscal year ending in June 2021. Much of the cutting will come from moving functions such as school crossing guards to other departments.

The remaining $439 million is from canceling a police-academy class and, especially, from a planned decrease in overtime. The Democratic mayor said this year’s lack of parades and sports will cut overtime needs. Budget projections show overtime bouncing back in future years.

In Los Angeles, city council members approved $150 million in cuts to the nearly $1.9 billion police budget. The city, which is already contractually obligated by an agreement last year to raise police salaries, expects to achieve the cuts by significantly reducing overtime and reducing the force through attrition, according to people familiar with the city’s affairs.

In Seattle, where protesters took over several blocks for three weeks in June, a spokeswoman for the mayor’s office said about half of the roughly $3 million police spending cut approved by the city council is to come from layoffs that must be bargained with the police union.

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is: Extended Excerpt Image 4


Albuquerque, N.M., is planning to shift some police functions to a new “community safety” department, which could respond to 911 calls by sending social workers, homelessness specialists and violence-prevention experts. Little of its funding will come from the roughly $210 million police budget, about 80% of which goes to labor costs, including retirement and increased salaries to combat an officer shortage.

Facing a violent-crime rate three times the national average, Albuquerque’s city council in 2018 raised sales taxes, mostly to increase the police and fire budgets. The city also has had to increase spending on police equipment and cap the number of officers per supervisor because of a federal settlement of allegations of use of excessive force.

For the community safety department’s $10 million or so budget, Albuquerque expects to be able to shift about $1 million from the police department—about half of one percent of the police budget.

U.S. public support for police increased after mass shootings in 2016, including the Orlando, Fla., Pulse nightclub attack and the targeted killing of five Dallas police officers. A Gallup poll later that year showed Americans’ respect for local police at its highest levels since 1967. A Pew poll the same year found a majority of respondents thought the police presence in their communities was the right size; more than a third wanted to see more police, and only 8% wanted fewer.

Support dropped following Mr. Floyd’s killing and the nationwide protests. In the Pew poll in June, just 34% of respondents said police did a good or excellent job of treating racial and ethnic groups equally, down from 47% in a Pew poll conducted in 2016.

Also lower was the share who said police do a good or excellent job of using the right amount of force; 35% said so, compared with 45% in 2016.

The roots of today’s U.S. police budgets trace to a surge late last century in the rate of violent crime. It rose from lows in the 1960s to a peak in the early 1990s of about 758 violent crimes per 100,000 people, according to Federal Bureau of Investigation statistics. A Wall Street Journal/NBC Poll in the early ’90s found 93% of respondents regarded dealing with crime as an absolute priority.

Cities Weigh Cutting Police Budgets and Discover How Hard That Is: Extended Excerpt Image 5


Starting in 1994, a federal initiative under President Clinton sent billions of dollars to small towns for police hiring. It prompted more than 300 towns to create brand-new police departments. Big cities made hiring police a priority. New York added 35% more officers per capita between 1993 and 1997, according to Bureau of Justice Statistics data.

Violent crimes fell by half from 1993 through 2018, to 369 per 100,000 Americans, according to FBI data. Arrest rates in the mid-2010s dropped to the lowest in decades.

Meanwhile, police mandates expanded. By 2016, more than 40% of departments serving 100,000 or more people had task forces on terrorism and cybercrimes. Police became the first government contact for people with troubles such as addiction, mental illness and homelessness. Officers increasingly were stationed in schools to protect and monitor students.

The officer facing murder charges for killing Rayshard Brooks in Atlanta wasn’t responding to a call about crime but about a man asleep in his car in a Wendy’s drive-through line.

“The job description has changed. It goes from just doing police work to states disinvesting in mental health, where now we have more and more crisis intervention,” said Calvin Williams, chief of Cleveland’s division of police.

Cleveland added body cameras and training aimed at reducing the use of force following a Justice Department investigation and a high-profile 2014 case in which a white officer shot and killed Tamir Rice, a Black 12-year-old boy who was carrying a plastic pellet gun. The city agreed to pay $6 million to the child’s family.

The cameras and the cost of paying other officers to fill in for those undergoing days of training were very expensive, said Cleveland’s Democratic mayor, Frank Jackson. “Racism is still here,” Mr. Jackson said. “And how do you keep it in check? Sometimes it costs money to do that.”

Some of what budget setters wrestle with can be seen in Santa Ana, Calif., population about 332,000, where the city council last year approved $25.6 million in salary and benefit increases for the police over three years, in a package negotiated with a police union.

Should the level of spending on police departments be changed? Join the conversation below.

Jose Solorio, a council member who voted for the increases, said he was concerned about crime. For every 100,000 people in 2018, Santa Ana logged 468 violent crimes, vs. the national average of 369.

“It was necessary to compete in hiring officers in a competitive environment,” Mr. Solorio said.

Santa Ana police officers are paid $88,692 to start, rising to $102,684 after 2.5 years, plus benefits. Sergeants and lieutenants earn more. Officers volunteered to delay a raise from the current level for six months to ease the pandemic’s effect on the budget.

Cecilia Iglesias was one of two council members who voted against the raises. “The additional money, the $25 million, that could have gone to a lot of services,” she said, such as programs for youth and seniors.

Ms. Iglesias lost her council seat in May. The Santa Ana Police Officers Association spent a total of about $300,000 seeking a recall election and then supporting her ouster after a recall vote was set, election filings show.

Association President Gerry Serrano said the union’s support for her recall wasn’t related to her vote. He said she “villainizes” those who work to provide public safety.

Ms. Iglesias said, “I support law enforcement and law and order.” She said it’s the police union she disagrees with.

Ed Comment:Good data on policing. Also Note, "The polling showed 58% of Americans support major changes to policing, but just 15% support abolishing the police." If half of Americans are dems then about a third of steve's newly supported party want to abolish the police. That's a party full of morons. MAGA.

“…Compensation makes up more than half of police department operating budgets, without counting benefit and pension costs, according to a Journal analysis of data from the Census Bureau and a Justice Department unit called the Bureau of Justice Statistics. Cities that pay below-market salaries risk losing officers to neighboring towns….”

  • Government Spending
  • Workforce
    • Poverty/Crime
Previous articleAugust 13, 2020Crime Roaring TwentiesBlacks Are 7.9x More Likely To Be Homicide Offenders Than Nonblacks According To FBI.Next articleAugust 13, 2020Weaker Dollars Means More Dollar ReservesDollar reserve holdings tend to increase when the dollar declines, driven by export-based economies with large external surpluses. @Brad_Setser
Showing 193 database articles primarily about Government Spending
Currently filtering by:
  • Remove 'Database'

The Fairest Way to Reform Social Security May Also Be the Worst Way to Grow the Economy

AI Summary. Fully closing Social Security's funding gap by raising the payroll tax rate would require an immediate, permanent increase from 12.4% to 17.6%, which would reduce labor supply and economic growth. Research on a prior benefit cut found affected Americans raised earnings by 61 cents per dollar of lost benefits, generating additional payroll tax revenue.

Andrew Biggs American Enterprise Institute
Date Posted:
May 28, 2026
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

Biggs argues that “fair” approaches to restoring Social Security solvency – those that do not cut already accrued benefits – are less effective than “unfair” ones that do, because the latter incentivize increased work effort, raising growth and revenue.

Biggs argues that “fair” approaches to restoring Social Security solvency – those that do not cut already accrued...

Does closing Social Security's gap with higher payroll taxes hurt growth?

Core argument: Keeping Social Security permanently solvent under the "fairness" model of paying accrued benefits in full would require an immediate and permanent payroll tax increase from 12.4% to 17.6%, which would decrease labor supply and reduce economic growth.

Imagine that Social Security reform follows the fairness model, in which accrued benefits are paid in full but the rate at which future benefits are earned is reduced. A simple way to do this is to increase the payroll tax rate To keep Social Security permanently solvent, meaning through 75 years and beyond, would require an immediate and permanent increase in the payroll tax rate [from] 12.4% to 17.6%. The higher rate would decrease labor supply and reduce economic growth. [Consider] an alternate reform, which looks clearly unfair: fix Social Security’s funding gap entirely by reducing accrued benefits that Americans already have earned. As of 2025, Americans had accrued $54 trillion in Social Security benefits. Social Security’s unfunded obligation as of 2025 was $26 trillion. So, roughly, this means cutting Americans’ “earned benefits” in half. [Analyzing the 1977 reform that undid the notorious 1972 “double-indexing” of benefits, a group of economists], using SSA earnings data, found that, for every dollar of lost benefits, the affected Americans increased their earnings by 61 cents. Moreover, these additional earnings would be taxed by Social Security, further strengthening the program’s finances. In effect, this makes cutting benefits a “cheaper” way to fix Social Security than raising taxes, because people respond in ways that also increase tax revenues.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Keeping Social Security permanently solvent under the "fairness" model of paying accrued benefits in full would require an immediate and permanent payroll tax increase from 12.4% to 17.6%, which would decrease labor supply and reduce economic growth.
  2. Americans had accrued $54 trillion in Social Security benefits as of 2025 against an unfunded obligation of $26 trillion, so closing the gap solely by cutting already-earned benefits would mean roughly halving those benefits.
  3. Economists analyzing the 1977 reform that undid the 1972 "double-indexing" of benefits found, using SSA earnings data, that affected Americans raised their earnings by 61 cents per dollar of lost benefits, earnings that Social Security would tax.

Related Articles:

  • Social Security and Trends in Wealth Inequality — The authors estimate that including Social Security in household wealth leaves top wealth shares little changed over three decades, with the top 10% and top 1% shares rising 1.1 and 1.6 percentage points versus roughly 9 and 6 points for marketable wealth alone. Social Security wealth grew from $7tn to $39tn.
  • How Federal Spending is Distributed by Age — An analysis classifying $4.4tn of $7tn in federal spending by age finds retirees aged 65 and older receive $2.7tn, 38.6% of total outlays and 61.9% of age-assignable spending, versus $1.2tn for working-age adults and $449bn for those under 26. Social Security and Medicare account for 80% of age-assignable spending on older adults.
  • The Great “Transfer”-mation — Government transfers rose from 8.2% of Americans' total personal income in 1970 to 17.6% in 2022, making them the third largest income source after work and investments. The share of U.S. counties drawing a quarter or more of personal income from transfers rose from under 1% in 1970 to 53% in 2022.
  • Government Spending
  • Fiscal Policy
    • Fiscal Deficits
    • Taxation

The World’s Most Surprising Capitalist Makeover Is Under Way in Sweden

AI Summary. Sweden has opened public services to private providers, with nearly half of primary healthcare clinics privately owned and one in three public high schools privately run, up from 20% in 2011. Its public social spending has fallen to 24% of GDP, similar to the US and below the over 30% in France and Italy.

Tom Fairless Wall Street Journal
Date Posted:
May 12, 2026
Is Database:
Database

Swedish public social spending is now 23.7% of GDP, just 1pp above that of the US and well under France’s 31.6%. Market-based reforms in the 1990s brought overall government spending down from 69.4% to 49.3% in 2024.

How has Sweden shrunk its state by privatizing public services?

Core argument: Sweden's total public social spending, covering healthcare, education and welfare payments, has fallen to 24% of GDP, similar to the U.S. and well below the over 30% of nations like France and Italy.

For decades, Sweden was shorthand for the brand of high-tax, high-spend government that managed people’s lives from cradle to grave through state-run hospitals, schools and care homes. No longer. With little fanfare, this Nordic country of 11 million has embraced capitalism. Today, nearly half of primary healthcare clinics are privately owned, many by private-equity firms. One in three public high schools is privately run, up from 20% in 2011. School operators are listed on the stock exchange. The capitalist makeover has allowed Sweden to do what few industrialized countries have managed in recent years: shrink the size of the state. That has enabled the government to sharply lower taxes and, economists say, sparked a surge in entrepreneurship and economic growth. Its total public social spending bill—which includes healthcare, education and all welfare payments—has fallen to 24% of gross domestic product, similar to the U.S. and well below the over 30% for nations like France and Italy. Sweden’s economy is expected to grow by around 2% a year through 2030, roughly the same pace as the U.S. and double the growth rates of France and Germany, according to an April forecast by the International Monetary Fund.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Sweden's total public social spending, covering healthcare, education and welfare payments, has fallen to 24% of GDP, similar to the U.S. and well below the over 30% of nations like France and Italy.
  2. Nearly half of Sweden's primary healthcare clinics are privately owned, many by private-equity firms, and one in three public high schools is privately run, up from 20% in 2011, with school operators listed on the stock exchange.
  3. An April forecast by the International Monetary Fund projects Sweden's economy will grow around 2% a year through 2030, roughly matching the U.S. and double the growth rates of France and Germany.

Related Articles:

  • How Sweden Overcame Socialism — After government spending reached 70% of GDP and public debt 80% of GDP, Sweden adopted market-oriented reforms including privatized healthcare services, for-profit schools, reduced welfare benefits, deregulation of electricity and transportation, and a corporate tax cut from 28% to 22%. Public debt has since fallen to 41% of GDP, with growth outpacing European Union peers by roughly 1 point annually.
  • Reforming the Welfare State: Recovery and Beyond in Sweden — Sweden's structural reforms — flexible exchange rates, inflation targeting, a smaller public sector, less generous social insurance, and deregulated markets — accompanied export-led growth, a current account surplus lasting over a decade, government spending falling to 52% of GDP, and central government debt dropping from nearly 80% of GDP to about half that.
  • The US Has One of the Highest Fertility Rates Among Peer Countries — The tempo-adjusted fertility rate, which accounts for shifts in the timing of births, shows the US rate falling since roughly 2009-10 and dropping below the 2.1 births-per-woman replacement level around 2017, reaching 1.82 in 2022. The US decline is less severe than in many peer countries.
  • Government Spending
  • Fiscal Policy
    • Fiscal Deficits
  • Politics

How Policy and Demographics Are Reshaping SNAP: From Families with Children to Older Adults

AI Summary. The share of the US population receiving food stamps doubled from 6% to 12% over roughly 25 years, with real costs per capita rising 179% to $279 a year, though both remain below their post-Great-Recession peak. Households with an elderly person now outnumber those with a child, reversing the early-2000s pattern.

Angela Rachidi American Enterprise Institute
Date Posted:
May 1, 2026
Is Database:
Database

About 40mm Americans, 12% of the population, receive SNAP benefits, up from 6% in 2000. In 2023, only 34% of these households included children, down from 49% in 2010, while 36% contained an elderly person, up from 16% in FY2010.

How have food stamp enrollment, costs, and recipient households changed?

Core argument: The share of the U.S. population receiving SNAP doubled from 6% in FY2000 to 12% in FY2025, while real SNAP costs per capita rose 179%, from roughly $100 to $279 per year in 2024 dollars.

Comparing FY2000 with FY2025, the share of the population receiving SNAP doubled from 6% to 12%, while real SNAP costs per capita increased by 179%—from roughly $100 per year to $279 (in 2024 dollars). Despite this growth, per capita participation and costs in FY2025 remained below their pre-pandemic peak in 2013, which coincided with the aftermath of the Great Recession and changes in eligibility and other policies stemming from the 2008 Farm Bill. SNAP is countercyclical, meaning that all else equal, the number of people receiving SNAP should rise during recessions because of increased unemployment and decline as the economy recovers, [though] overall SNAP participation has grown faster than changes in the unemployment rate alone would predict. Over the long run, and especially since FY2020 (due to the Thrifty Food Plan’s increase in the maximum SNAP benefit), costs per capita have not returned to prerecession levels after a period of high unemployment. In FY2023, the share of SNAP households containing an elderly person (36%) exceeded the share containing a child (34%) for the first time. This was a sharp departure from the early 2000s, when more than half of SNAP households contained a child and less than 20% included an elderly person (Figure 2).

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. The share of the U.S. population receiving SNAP doubled from 6% in FY2000 to 12% in FY2025, while real SNAP costs per capita rose 179%, from roughly $100 to $279 per year in 2024 dollars.
  2. In FY2023, the share of SNAP households containing an elderly person reached 36%, exceeding the 34% containing a child for the first time, against the early 2000s when over half contained a child and under 20% included an elderly person.

Related Articles:

  • The Great “Transfer”-mation — Government transfers rose from 8.2% of Americans' total personal income in 1970 to 17.6% in 2022, making them the third largest income source after work and investments. The share of U.S. counties drawing a quarter or more of personal income from transfers rose from under 1% in 1970 to 53% in 2022.
  • Poverty and Dependency in the United States, 1939–2023 — Extending a consistent poverty measure back to 1939, the authors estimate US absolute poverty fell from 48.5% to 19.5% between 1939 and 1963, driven by growth in market income rather than government transfers net of taxes. Poverty fell no faster in the 24 years after the War on Poverty than before.
  • Government Benefit Programs Already Do A Lot To Help Low Income Families — For a two-adult, three-child family, existing taxes and government benefits bring take-home resources to about $58,000 with no earnings, $79,000 with $20,000 of earnings, and $90,000 with $80,000 of earnings plus $15,000 in employer health premiums. A $75,000 gap in earnings and work-related benefits narrows to $11,000 in take-home pay.
  • Government Spending
  • Fiscal Policy
  • Workforce
    • Poverty/Crime

Washington’s Growing Portfolio: Tracking U.S. Government Investments

AI Summary. The U.S. government has invested $20.9bn across sixteen deals taking direct ownership stakes, expanding beyond its traditional toolkit of grants, loans, and tax incentives. The Department of Defense leads with seven deals, the Department of Commerce has six including a 10% stake in Intel, and partners have mobilized an additional $4.75bn.

Jonathan Hillman Council On Foreign Relations
Date Posted:
April 23, 2026
Is Database:
Database

Since January 2025, the USG has taken equity stakes totaling $20.9B in 16 American businesses. $8.6B, ~41% of the total, was invested in critical mineral miners and processors, while $8.9B, ~43% of the total, funded the government’s 10% stake in Intel.

Is the U.S. government taking direct equity stakes in companies?

Core argument: Since January 2025, the U.S. government has invested $20.9 billion across sixteen deals involving direct ownership, broadening a toolkit traditionally focused on grants, loans, and tax incentives.

Since January 2025, the U.S. government has invested $20.9 billion across sixteen deals involving direct ownership, broadening a toolkit that has traditionally focused on grants, loans, and tax incentives. The Department of Commerce has participated in six such deals, including taking a 10% stake in Intel. The Development Finance Corporation, the United States’ development bank, has executed three equity transactions in critical minerals, healthcare, and infrastructure. The Department of Defense leads the way with seven such deals. The U.S. government is also working with a range of partners and has mobilized an additional $4.75 billion in investment. Private co-investors include J.P. Morgan, Goldman Sachs, and others.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Since January 2025, the U.S. government has invested $20.9 billion across sixteen deals involving direct ownership, broadening a toolkit traditionally focused on grants, loans, and tax incentives.
  2. The Department of Defense leads with seven direct-ownership deals, followed by the Department of Commerce with six, including a 10% stake in Intel, while the Development Finance Corporation has executed three equity transactions in critical minerals, healthcare, and infrastructure.
  3. The U.S. government has mobilized an additional $4.75 billion in investment alongside private co-investors including J.P. Morgan and Goldman Sachs.

Related Articles:

  • Industrial Policy and Economic Security — Industrial policy justified on national security grounds requires weighing how much economic inefficiency is worth tolerating, since costs incurred today make a country poorer and therefore less able to project power later. The calculation is difficult because security gains are probabilistic and long-term economic costs are speculative.
  • The Cold War and the U.S. Labor Market — The authors estimate that declining U.S. military procurement spending from the 1950s to the 1990s explains roughly 18–30% of the decline in manufacturing employment and just under 10% of the rise in top-decile income inequality. They argue Cold War procurement raised demand for manufacturing workers and helped sustain tight labor markets for low-skill workers.
  • Capital Is Making a Comeback — Tangible investment in property, factories and equipment fell from 12.5% to 8.5% of private gross domestic product, while intangible investment in intellectual property, software and process knowledge rose from about 11.5% to 16.75%. The author argues demand for tangible capital investment will now have to rise.
  • Government Spending
  • Fiscal Policy
  • Politics
  • Productivity
    • Investment
  • Security

How Federal Spending is Distributed by Age

AI Summary. An analysis classifying $4.4tn of $7tn in federal spending by age finds retirees aged 65 and older receive $2.7tn, 38.6% of total outlays and 61.9% of age-assignable spending, versus $1.2tn for working-age adults and $449bn for those under 26. Social Security and Medicare account for 80% of age-assignable spending on older adults.

Kent Smetters University of Pennsylvania
Date Posted:
April 2, 2026
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

In 2025, of the 62.5% of Federal spending that is age-assignable on a per-capita basis, US retirees aged 65+ were given $43,700, working-age adults 26–64 got $7,300, and children and young adults got $4,300.

How is federal spending distributed across age groups?

Core argument: Retirees aged 65 and older receive $2.7 trillion of federal spending in fiscal 2025, equal to 38.6% of total outlays and 61.9% of age-assignable spending, versus $1.2 trillion for working-age adults aged 26–64.

We trace spending items within 52 general spending categories, totalling $7T for the 2025 Fiscal Year. We are able to classify a total of $4.4T across three broad age categories and assign the remaining $2.6T to an all-ages residual. Retirees (adults age 65 and older) receive $2.7T, equal to 38.6% of total federal outlays and 61.9% of age-assignable spending. Working-age adults (ages 26-64) receive $1.2T (27.9% of age-assignable), and children and young adults (under age 26) receive $449B (10.3%). The dominance of the retiree category reflects two programs above all others: Social Security and Medicare. Social Security directs $1.3T to retirees, and Medicare sends $835B. Together, they account for 80% of all age-assignable spending on older adults. But the retiree total extends beyond these two entitlements. Federal employee retirement benefits ($169B), housing assistance for older households, Medicaid long-term-care spending, and VA medical care all contribute, making the federal budget more retiree-focused than a Social Security–only lens would suggest.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Retirees aged 65 and older receive $2.7 trillion of federal spending in fiscal 2025, equal to 38.6% of total outlays and 61.9% of age-assignable spending, versus $1.2 trillion for working-age adults aged 26–64.
  2. Children and young adults under age 26 receive $449 billion, or 10.3% of age-assignable federal spending, out of $4.4 trillion classified by age within a $7 trillion budget, with $2.6 trillion assigned to an all-ages residual.
  3. Social Security directs $1.3 trillion and Medicare $835 billion to retirees, together 80% of age-assignable spending on older adults, with federal employee retirement benefits ($169 billion), housing assistance, Medicaid long-term care, and VA medical care contributing further.

Related Articles:

  • The Great “Transfer”-mation — Government transfers rose from 8.2% of Americans' total personal income in 1970 to 17.6% in 2022, making them the third largest income source after work and investments. The share of U.S. counties drawing a quarter or more of personal income from transfers rose from under 1% in 1970 to 53% in 2022.
  • France and Britain Are In Thrall To Pensioners — French pensioners receive larger government payments than in any other western country and begin receiving them several years earlier, leaving over-65s with higher average incomes than the working-age population — a situation without precedent internationally or in France's own history. Proposals to raise the retirement age or delay pension increases have triggered nationwide protests and government collapses.
  • The Budgetary Impact of the Abandonment of Federalism — Federal spending on activities originally regarded as state, local, or private-sector responsibilities is estimated to have risen from 2% of GDP in 1950 to 14% in 2019, exceeding the entire growth in federal spending over that period and reaching two-thirds of all federal outlays. Aid to individuals accounts for 80% of that increase, grants to states the remaining 20%.
  • Government Spending
  • Fiscal Policy
    • Fiscal Deficits
  • Healthcare/Seniors
  • Workforce
    • Poverty/Crime

Has the United States Bent the Health Care Cost Curve?

AI Summary. The authors estimate that a slowdown in US health care spending reflects technology-associated changes in health and site of care (21% of the slowdown, double that in Medicare), more elastic long-run supply (6%), market changes reducing and making demand more elastic (11–27%), improved population health (7%), and slower price growth net of upcoding (24%).

David Cutler and Lev Klarnet Brookings Papers On Economic Activity
Date Posted:
March 30, 2026
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

In 2024, medical spending as a share of GDP was just above its 2010 level and 15% ($977B) below its 2010 forecast; 21% of the gap was due to technology, 24% to price reductions, and 11–27% to reforms such as prior authorization and higher deductibles.

What explains the slowdown in US health care spending?

Core argument: Technology-associated changes in health and site of care account for 21% of the overall U.S. health care cost slowdown and double that share in Medicare, according to the authors' estimates.

Five factors are important in the slowdown in spending [Figure 16]. The first is technology-associated changes in health and site of care. These correspond to the subsequent innovations in our model. Together, technologies along these lines account for 21% of the overall cost slowdown and double that in Medicare. Second, long-run supply is more elastic than short-run supply, which lowers spending over time. This is particularly apparent in the impact of patent expiration for pharmaceuticals and in relative declines in imaging reimbursement. We estimate that greater long-run supply explains 6% of the spending slowdown. Third, a variety of market changes contribute to reduced and more elastic demand, including increased cost sharing paid by consumers, physicians not paid as much for using technologies, and insurers imposing restrictions on technology use - a rough guess is that these account for 11 to 27% of the spending slowdown. Fourth, the population is healthier in ways that reduce spending. This includes fewer hospitalizations for smoking-related conditions and reduced need for formal home health care. The birth rate has fallen as well, which reduces the need for care. We estimate improved population health explains 7% of the spending slowdown. A major component is slower price growth. Net of upcoding, we estimate lower price growth explains 24% of the spending slowdown.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Technology-associated changes in health and site of care account for 21% of the overall U.S. health care cost slowdown and double that share in Medicare, according to the authors' estimates.
  2. The authors estimate that slower price growth, net of upcoding, explains 24% of the health care spending slowdown, while market changes reducing demand — higher consumer cost sharing, lower physician payment for technology use, and insurer restrictions — account for a rough 11–27%.
  3. Improved population health explains an estimated 7% of the spending slowdown, through fewer smoking-related hospitalizations, reduced need for formal home health care, and a lower birth rate, while greater long-run supply elasticity explains 6%.

Related Articles:

  • Sick as a Dog — US healthcare stocks tracked technology-sector returns from 1989 to 2019 with lower volatility (15% vs 24%), but have since stagnated as technology advanced. Major pharmaceutical firms trade at forward price-to-earnings ratios of 8x–9x, biotech carries one of the market's largest valuation discounts, and 80% of biotech initial public offerings since 2018 have collapsed.
  • Saved by Medicaid: New Evidence on Health Insurance and Mortality from the Universe of Low-Income Adults — Using linked Census and tax records for 37m low-income adults, the authors estimate that state Medicaid expansions raised enrollment by 12 percentage points and cut mortality among low-income adults by 2.5%, implying a 21% reduction in the mortality hazard of new enrollees. They estimate direct budgetary costs of $5.4m per life saved and $179,000 per life-year saved.
  • The Great “Transfer”-mation — Government transfers rose from 8.2% of Americans' total personal income in 1970 to 17.6% in 2022, making them the third largest income source after work and investments. The share of U.S. counties drawing a quarter or more of personal income from transfers rose from under 1% in 1970 to 53% in 2022.
  • Government Spending
  • Fiscal Policy
    • Fiscal Deficits
  • Healthcare/Seniors
© Copyright 2026 Coherent Research Institute · All Rights Reserved · Privacy · Terms