Does the bullish AI case rest on a rare rebound effect?
Core argument: Rebound effects from improved energy efficiency are typically not large enough to fully offset the initial savings, and the Jevons paradox — where the sum of all rebounds exceeds those savings — is quite rare.
The Jevons paradox is a form of a broader phenomenon known as “rebound effects”. These are typically not large enough to fully offset savings from improved efficiency. Usually they are examined by academics and policymakers keen to use less energy: environmental worries about peak coal turned into worries about peak oil and then into worries about greenhouse gases. Sometimes the effect is straightforward: tighter fuel standards, designed to lower emissions, lead American drivers to travel longer distances. Sometimes it is less direct: better-insulated houses have increased the size of windows in Europe, offsetting efficiency gains. Sometimes it is macroeconomic: less energy use by one industry frees up supply for another. The Jevons paradox occurs when the sum of all the rebounds is larger than the initial energy savings—and it is really quite rare. Basing the bull case for AI on the Jevons paradox is, therefore, a bet not on the efficiency of the technology but on the level of demand.


