Is renewable growth adding to fossil fuel use rather than replacing it?
Core argument: Renewables have grown as a share of total energy supply while fossil fuel production has risen in absolute terms, leaving total energy supply and greenhouse gas emissions at all-time highs — an energy addition rather than a transition.
We are looking at an energy addition, not an energy transition. Despite the last decade’s ambitious goals of investing in renewable energy and phasing out fossil fuels, what we’ve seen so far has been an addition of renewable energy supply, not a transition away from fossil fuels. With climate goals increasingly deprioritized and total demand for power continuing to increase, we would expect this trend to continue. While renewables have increased as a share of total energy supply, in absolute terms fossil fuel production has been rising as well. This nets out to total energy supply and greenhouse gas emissions being at all-time highs, reflecting the “all of the above” demand for greater quantity and redundancy in energy supply chains. The shift in policy priorities away from climate leadership will also drive a shift in investment toward the most economically viable energy sources—but renewables aren’t dead.

