Is the shift of government bond holdings to nonbanks a risk?
Core argument: Non-bank financial institutions' holdings of financial assets rose 74 percentage points relative to global GDP between 2008 and 2023, compared with a rise of 17 percentage points for banks.
Rising public debt is one concern. Another is how it is being financed. The ratio of NBFI holdings of financial assets to global GDP rose 74pp between 2008 and 2023, while that of banks rose by only 17pp. Hernández de Cos [of the BIS] warns that the combination of rising government bond issuance with the post-financial crisis retrenchment of banks created a steadily growing gap between the supply of government bonds and the assets of bank dealers needed to support the capacity of these crucial markets to intermediate. NBFIs are a heterogeneous group. A vital distinction is between “real money” investors, such as pension funds and insurers, and leveraged speculators, notably hedge funds. The former group of long-term private investors has greatly increased its holdings of government bonds, from an amount worth 82% of global GDP in 2008 to one of 135% in 2023. Meanwhile, money market funds and hedge funds have also increased the value of their holdings from 13% to 18% of global GDP over these years. Many of these NBFIs also need to hedge foreign currency risks, given the rise in their cross-border holdings. This has caused a huge jump in their reliance on foreign currency swaps.

