How much tightening do rich countries need to stabilize debt ratios?
Core argument: The Economist calculates that most rich countries could still run small primary deficits and keep debt stable as a share of GDP even if all their debt were refinanced immediately at today's rates, with Britain needing the largest primary surplus at 0.3% of GDP.
The Economist calculates that most rich countries could still run small primary deficits [deficits net of interest payments] and keep debts stable as a share of their economies, even if they had to refinance all their debt immediately at today’s rates. The largest primary surplus required to balance debts is in Britain, at just 0.3% of GDP. That is not large for countries in a pinch. In the late 1990s Italy ran primary surpluses of 3-6% of GDP to bring down debts before joining the euro. In Britain and America, deficits are large. The belt tightening needed to stabilise the debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds 2% of GDP; in France it is greater than 3% of GDP. Things look worse still when you consider the coming wave of spending on ageing populations, defence and the climate transition. And higher debt interest costs to come are not yet fully accounted for. About half of outstanding debt with a fixed interest rate in the OECD club of rich countries costs less than 2% a year to service —a legacy of having issued the debt when rates were low. American debt worth a quarter of the country’s GDP will come due between 2025 and 2027. Reissuing it at 2024 yields would increase the interest rate paid by about two percentage points.

