How much federal aid to states did each government job-year cost?
Core argument: The authors estimate that each $878,000 of pandemic-era federal aid to state and local governments created or preserved one state or local government job-year, a fairly small jobs multiplier.
Federal assistance generated fairly small (jobs) multipliers. We found that each $878,000 in federal assistance created or preserved one state or local job-year. About a third of the effect size is driven by spillovers from other states. More important than the point estimate itself, however, are the values we can rule out on the basis of our estimates’ confidence intervals. We can rule out an estimate that federal fiscal assistance saved a state or local government job-year at a cost of less than $428,000, making fiscal assistance far less effective at supporting employment during the pandemic than during the global financial crisis.



