Does a one-time wealth tax still give billionaires reason to leave?
Core argument: California’s Prop 40 one-time 5% wealth tax leaves billionaires with incentives to leave the state after the snapshot date, contrary to Gabriel Zucman’s claim that one cannot avoid the tax by moving.
[Responding to Gabriel Zucman's claim, “There is no incentive to move to another state. One cannot avoid the tax by moving. This is one of the main reasons why it was structured as a one-time tax.”] Billionaires still have incentives to leave after the snapshot date. They may reasonably question whether the retroactive residency provision will ultimately survive the many legal challenges it will face, and the passage of the tax may alter their expectations about future wealth taxation. Even if billionaires consider the initial 5% tax insufficient reason to leave California, the belief in the possibility of future, additional wealth taxes could change their decision-making, regardless of whether those taxes ultimately occur or not. This is not an unreasonable or merely hypothetical concern. Zucman himself has called the fight over California’s Prop 40 “the beginning of a global movement to end the ultra-rich’s ability to escape taxation with impunity.” Additionally, fellow Prop 40 proponent Emmanuel Saez said back in June that “we will have to see whether this one passes and then whether it makes sense to do a permanent wealth tax down the road.”

