Is Eastern Europe converging with the US while Western Europe falls behind?
Core argument: Western Europe moved the opposite way, with Italy falling from 93% of the US per capita GDP level to 68%, France from 86% to 71%, Spain from 72% to 61%, and Portugal from 64% to 57%.
While we have spent a decade complaining about Europe’s stagnation, a real positive convergence story has been unfolding at the eastern edge of the continent. Poland entered the millennium at 34% of US per capita GDP; by 2030, the IMF projects it will reach 67%. Romania rises from 27% to 60%. Lithuania moves from 29% to 69%. Bulgaria goes from 23% to 53%. These countries’ citizens are still significantly poorer than Americans. But they have closed a large part of the gap with the global frontier. Meanwhile, at the other end of the continent, the picture is almost the mirror image. Portugal slipped from 64% to 57%. Spain fell from 72% to 61%. The richer laggards are more striking: France dropped from 86% of the US level to 71%, and Italy fell from 93% to 68%. The hope in Europe after the Draghi report was that the Russian threat to the east would supply the political urgency the reform agendas in the “stuck” [Western] part of Europe lack. The correlation created by the crisis is the wrong one. The Russian shock is mobilising the countries where the Draghi problem is not most severe, and leaving the countries where it is most severe largely untouched. War is reforming Europe’s frontier. It is not reforming Europe’s rear, and on present evidence, it will not.


