Does immigration outflow lower the break-even rate for job growth?
Core argument: Payroll growth over December 2025–February 2026 slightly exceeded the estimated break-even rate on average, consistent with the unemployment rate remaining stable despite softer headline payroll numbers.
Comparing our break-even estimates with actual payroll growth (Chart 2, blue bars) suggests that job growth over the recent three months—December 2025–February 2026—has slightly exceeded the break-even rate on average, consistent with the unemployment rate remaining stable despite softer headline payroll numbers. Real-time data point to an important change in the U.S. labor market: The benchmark for evaluating payroll growth has moved significantly. As net outflows of unauthorized immigrants reduce employment growth in late 2025, payroll gains that might historically have signalled economic slack are now consistent with a balanced labor market.


