Is China's housing market still weighing on consumer spending?
Core argument: China's housing market has yet to find a bottom five years after the "three red lines" and related restrictions were imposed, though the pace of decline is now more gradual.
Housing is yet to find a bottom five years after the imposition of the “three red lines” and other restrictions--while the pace of decline is more gradual now, a small but growing number of households are in a negative home equity position, and adverse spillovers to local government finances and infrastructure spending continue to play out. Consumer spending is lagging as home price declines erode household balance sheets, a weak labor market is providing only slow income growth, and the boost from government trade-in programs has peaked.



![Due to quotas resulting from a Biden DEI initiative, “Black [Naval Academy] applicants scoring in the fourth decile had an...](https://i0.wp.com/www.edwardconard.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/logo-wall-street-journal.png?fit=320%2C160&ssl=1)
