The Alpha Beta Gamma of the Labor Market
- Date Posted:
- Is Database:
- Database
17% of American workers are low marginal product workers, contributing less to output relative to their employment cost, with 70% leaving their jobs within a year.

Victoria Gregory, Guido Menzio, and David Wiczer, "The Alpha Beta Gamma of the Labor Market," Federal Reserve Bank Of St. Louis, April 2021, https://s3.amazonaws.com/real.stlouisfed.org/wp/2021/2021-003.pdf



Ed Comment:. I edited my claim that low skilled workers turn over frequently form my Harvard Q&A because I only had my experience to back it up (and I didn’t want to talk about Bain’s portfolio companies but this provides the evidence. Highlight this factoid (the reason for including the entry): 70% of low-skilled workers (who represent 17% of workers) leave their job within a year.
Research from FRBSL breaks American workforce into three types of workers in terms of quality. By their measure (though my descriptive words, only 57% of America workers are high quality, and 17% of American workers are effectively low marginal product workers, for example high likelihood of leaving a job within 3m
α (57% of workers)"...On average, α workers have the shortest unemployment spells, the highest likelihood of reaching 2 years of tenure on the same job, and the highest labor income while employed...."so high quality workers.
γ (17% of workers)"...In contrast,γ workers have the longest unemployment spells, a very high likelihood of leaving a job within the first quarter from its inception, a very low likelihood of reaching two years of tenure on a job, and the lowest income while employed...."so low quality, ~ low marginal product workers
β (26% of workers)"...Workers of type β are in between α’s and γ’s..."
What these groups look like by age, gender and educational attainment, "...Using the output of the k-means algorithm, we can assign each individual worker in the data to a particular type. We can then compute the average of some observable characteristics for different types of workers. We find that the average birth year is 1963 for α-workers, 1964 for β-workers and 1967 for γ-workers. These small age differences seem to rule out the possibility that the algorithm simply picks out differences in transition patters that are related to the life cycle of a worker.We find that the fraction of women is 48% for α-workers, 49% for β-workers, and 46% for γ-workers. Again, we take this evidence that the algorithm is not splitting workers based on gender. Lastly, the fraction of workers with some college education is 62% for α workers, 56% for β-workers, and 50% for γ-workers. Along this dimension, there are starker differences, and yet having some college education hardly predicts a worker’s type..."
Core findings, "....Different types of workers have very different patterns of labor market transitions. First, consider the distribution of job durations for different types. For α-workers, the fraction of job spells lasting less than 1 quarter is 14% and the fraction of job spells lasting more than 2 years is 44%. For β-workers, the fraction of job spells lasting less than 1 quarter is 20% and the fraction of job spells lasting more than 2 years is 33%. For γ-workers, the fraction of job spells lasting less than 1 quarter is 36%, and the fraction of job spells lasting more than 2 years is 12%. That is, α-workers are 50% more likely to remain in the same job for more than 2 years than β-workers and 400% more likely than γ-workers. Conversely, γ-workers are 100% more likely to leave a job within 1 quarter than β-workers, and 300% more likely than α-workers. Second, consider the distribution of unemployment durations for different types. For α workers, the fraction of unemployment spells lasting less than 1 quarter is 79% and the fraction of spells lasting more than 1 year is only 5%. For β-workers, the fraction of unemployment spells lasting less than 1 quarter is 39% and the fraction of spells lasting more than 1 year is 5%. For γ-workers, the fraction of unemployment spells lasting less than 1 quarter is 55% but the fraction of spells lasting more than 1 year is 13%. That is, α-workers typically have short unemployment spells and very rarely have long ones; β-workers are less likely to have short unemployment spells but they also have very few long ones; γ-workers are much more likely to experience long unemployment spells compared to αs and βs. The average time spent in unemployment is 3.5% for an α-worker, 9.6% for a β-worker, and 29.2% for a γ-worker. Overall, our classification of workers into types paints a clear picture. Workers of type α are likely to remain on a job for a long period of time and, when they do move into unemployment, they find a new job very quickly. Workers of type β are less likely to remain on a job for a long period of time and, when they move into unemployment, it takes them longer to find a new job. However, workers of type β are unlikely to be stuck into unemployment for more than a year. Workers of type γ are most likely to leave a job within two years. When they do become unemployed, they face a significant probability of becoming long-term unemployed..."