“Unintended Consequences represents the most cogent and persuasive analysis of the Financial Crisis to date.” - Andrei Shleifer, 1999 John Bates Clark Medal Winner
“Unintended Consequences should be read by anyone who takes for granted the superiority of progressive taxation and has not thought carefully about the trade-offs involved.” - The New Republic
“…challenges misconceptions that distort our economic debates.” - Arthur Brooks, President of the American Enterprise Institute
“…challenges misconceptions that distort our economic debates.” - Arthur Brooks, President of the American Enterprise Institute
“…a fresh argument for the productive value of inequality.” - David Autor, Professor of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
“…a very valuable contribution.” - Larry Summers, former Secretary of the Treasury and director of the National Economic Council, president emeritus, Harvard University
“Unintended Consequences is far smarter and more thought-provoking than most economics written for the general public” - Greg Mankiw, Harvard University, Former Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisors
“…serious thinking for serious thinkers. …a thought-provoking blueprint for growing middle- and working-class incomes.” - Mitt Romney, former Governor of Massachusetts
“…serious thinking for serious thinkers. …a thought-provoking blueprint for growing middle- and working-class incomes.” - Mitt Romney, former Governor of Massachusetts
“…reminds us that inequality sends a signal of what society lacks most, in America’s case, entrepreneurship and risk taking.” - Lawrence Lindsey, CEO, The Lindsey Group, former Director of the National Economic Council
“…a must-read for serious students of economic policy.” - Glenn Hubbard, Dean, Columbia Business School, and former Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers
“Unintended Consequences offers deep and well-argued analyses on almost every issue.” - The New York Times
AI Summary.Analysis across four U.S. datasets finds no significant trend in male earnings volatility over the past 35 years, with individual datasets showing modest increases or declines that align once earnings distributions are standardized. Volatility levels differ across datasets, which the authors attribute to differences in the earnings distributions covered.
Robert A. MoffittNational Bureau of Economic Research
Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Male earnings volatility remains stable: 35-year analysis of SIPP/PSID data shows no significant trend. Dataset differences reflect distribution variance, not true volatility shifts 1999-2010.
Has male earnings volatility trended up or down over decades?
Core argument: Male earnings volatility shows no significant trend change over the past 35 years across SIPP survey data, the SIPP Gold Standard File, and the Panel Study of Income Dynamics.
Analysis of male earnings volatility using SIPP [Survey of Income and Program Participation] survey data, SIPP GSF [Gold Standard File], and PSID [Panel Study of Income Dynamics] reveals no significant trend changes over the past 35 years. While SIPP GSF shows modest volatility increases and SIPP survey data shows declines, both datasets align when earnings distributions are standardized. Volatility levels differ across datasets, with SIPP GSF higher than PSID and SIPP survey lower, yet all show smaller relative increases between 1999-2010. The study underscores that differences in earnings distribution contribute to perceived volatility discrepancies, but overall, no major upward or downward trend is evident across multiple datasets, reinforcing the stability of male earnings volatility over the long term.
Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI
Male earnings volatility shows no significant trend change over the past 35 years across SIPP survey data, the SIPP Gold Standard File, and the Panel Study of Income Dynamics.
The SIPP Gold Standard File shows modest increases in male earnings volatility while SIPP survey data shows declines, but the two align once earnings distributions are standardized.
Volatility levels differ across the datasets, with the SIPP Gold Standard File higher than the PSID and SIPP survey data lower, yet all three show smaller relative increases between 1999 and 2010.
Moffitt took a look at the research looking at male earnings volatility and attempted to adjudicate it, finds little change in male earnings volatility in the past 35 years
Note attached copy is from a version of the paper from July 2020
"In this paper we compare estimates of earnings volatility from SIPP survey data and the SIPP GSF, which links SIPP survey respondents to their respective administrative earnings records. We show that the trends in the SIPP survey and the SIPP GSF are similar. Volatility increases modestly in the SIPP GSF and declines modestly in the SIPP survey data between the mid-1980s and the early 2010s. Levels in the SIPP GSF are considerably higher than in the SIPP survey data. The results are robust to age-adjusting, more aggressively trimming low earnings, the use of imputations, and different methods of handling population representativeness. We also show that differences in the underlying earnings distribution explain the differences in the trend and level of volatility in the SIPP GSF and SIPP survey data. When we force the earnings distributions in the two datasets to be the same, we find that the differences in levels of volatility largely disappear, and the minor differences in trends that exist are reduced. This paper is part of a larger project designed to consider estimates of earnings volatility across multiple datasets. As part of this project, we also compare volatility in the SIPP GSF and SIPP survey data to that in PSID. We compare volatility using the same sample selection criteria and methods and find that there remain differences in both the level and trend in volatility. Volatility in the SIPP GSF is higher than the PSID, while volatility in the SIPP survey is lower, and both shower smaller relative increases between 1999 and 2010. Even when the earnings distributions are forced to be the same across the three datasets, there remain differences in both level and trend in volatility between the SIPP and the PSID. We find that, for both the SIPP GSF and the SIPP, survey volatility falls to a lower level than the PSID when weighting the cross-sectional earning distribution to the PSID, implying that volatility is higher in the PSID at a fixed level of inequality. More broadly, the results of this paper and the other papers in this group have important implications for the broader literature on volatility. Using 3 different survey data sets and 3 different administrative data sets, we find broad agreement that volatility has shown no major trend upward or downward in the past 35 years. Thus our paper, along with the others, finds no difference in the evidence obtained from survey and administration data. Another finding that has broad applicability is that, in some cases, differences in the underlying cross-sectional earnings distribution in different data sets plays a role in explaining differences in both levels and trends in volatility. The substantial differences across data sources in the level of inequality, across methods used to estimate volatility in the weight placed on different portions of the earnings distribution, and across sample definitions that may themselves alter the level and trend in inequality, could contribute to some of the disagreement that has developed in this literature...."
Robert A. Moffitt, "Reconciling Trends in U.S. Male Earnings Volatility: Results from a Four Data Set Project," National Bureau Of Economic Research, August 2020, https://www.nber.org/papers/w27664
AI Summary.A shortage of U.S. blue collar workers, driven by a shrinking supply of manual and low-pay service labor as the workforce becomes more educated and less willing to take such jobs, is raising wages for those positions and narrowing wage inequality. Retiring baby boomers and stigma around light industrial work leave physically demanding jobs hard to fill.
Rich MillerBloomberg
Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
The US labor market is shifting due to a shortage of blue collar workers, driven by a shrinking supply of manual & low-pay service workers as the labor force becomes more educated & less willing to take on such jobs @RichMiller
Is a blue collar worker shortage raising wages and narrowing inequality?
Core argument: A shortage of U.S. blue collar workers is raising wages for manual and low-pay service jobs and narrowing wage inequality, as the labor force becomes more educated and less willing to take such positions.
The U.S. labor market is experiencing a significant shift due to a shortage of blue collar workers, driven by a shrinking supply of manual and low-pay service workers as the labor force becomes more educated and less willing to take on such jobs. This shortage is boosting wages for blue collar positions and narrowing wage inequality, while also drawing more women into these roles. The challenge is exacerbated as baby boomers retire, leaving manufacturers and companies with physically demanding jobs struggling to fill positions. Younger workers are increasingly pursuing educational alternatives or avoiding these jobs due to the stigma associated with light industrial work. This trend highlights a critical need for policy adjustments to address the evolving labor market dynamics.
Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI
A shortage of U.S. blue collar workers is raising wages for manual and low-pay service jobs and narrowing wage inequality, as the labor force becomes more educated and less willing to take such positions.
Baby boomer retirements are deepening the shortfall, leaving manufacturers and companies with physically demanding jobs struggling to fill positions while younger workers pursue educational alternatives or avoid light industrial work because of its stigma.
The blue collar labor shortage is drawing more women into manual and low-pay service roles.
Not sure if educational attainment is the best proxy here
"...A surprise shortage of blue collar workers is changing the contours of the U.S. labor market, boosting their pay, narrowing wage inequality and drawing more women into those jobs. The shortfall is being driven by a shrinking supply of manual and low-pay service workers as the labor force becomes more educated and less willing to take on such jobs, according to a new Conference Board study.....“The acute shortage of talent in the blue collar space is very, very pronounced,” said Peter Quigley, executive vice president at Kelly Services Inc., a staffing company with branches in all 50 U.S. states. Manufacturers and other companies with physically demanding jobs are finding it tough to fill those positions when baby boomers retire. “It’s harder and harder to attract younger people into those jobs, either because they’re pursuing education alternatives or the stigma associated with light industrial work,” Quigley said....."