AI Summary. Analysis of ancient DNA from 15,836 West Eurasians estimates selection coefficients at 9.7m genetic variants and finds pervasive directional selection, including increases in genetic scores for light skin pigmentation and negative selection against variants linked to type 2 diabetes risk and psychoses such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

Ancient DNA from 15,836 West Eurasians reveals that natural selection accelerated dramatically in the past 10,000 years, following the agricultural revolution. The strongest selection drove improved immune function and lighter skin pigmentation.

Has human genetic selection continued to shape traits across West Eurasia?

Core argument: Applying a new test for directional selection to ancient DNA from 15,836 West Eurasians, 10,016 with newly reported data, the authors estimate selection coefficients at 9.7 million variants to study how selection shapes the genetic architecture of complex traits.

We present a method for detecting directional selection in ancient DNA time-series data that tests for consistent trends in allele frequency change over time, and apply it to 15,836 West Eurasians (10,016 with new data). We estimate selection coefficients at 9.7 million variants, enabling study of how Darwinian forces couple to allelic effects and shape the genetic architecture of complex traits. We focused on 12 traits of particular interest with significant signals from all three tests (Figure 4). One of the strongest signals is an increase over time in the PGS for light skin pigmentation. Type 2 diabetes risk factors give compelling signals of negative selection. We detected negative polygenic selection against alleles associated today with psychoses such as bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. We finally observed signals of selection for combinations of alleles that today are associated with three correlated behavioural traits: scores on intelligence tests, household income and years of schooling. An important caveat is [that] these effects were measured in industrialized societies, and it remains unclear how these relate to phenotypes that were adaptive in the past.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Applying a new test for directional selection to ancient DNA from 15,836 West Eurasians, 10,016 with newly reported data, the authors estimate selection coefficients at 9.7 million variants to study how selection shapes the genetic architecture of complex traits.
  2. Among 12 traits with significant signals from all three tests, one of the strongest is an increase over time in the polygenic score for light skin pigmentation, alongside negative selection on type 2 diabetes risk factors and on alleles associated today with bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.
  3. The authors observed signals of selection on combinations of alleles associated today with intelligence test scores, household income, and years of schooling, while cautioning that these effects were measured in industrialized societies and their relation to past adaptive phenotypes remains unclear.

AI Summary. A meta-analysis found that polygenic scores, person-specific aggregates of inherited DNA differences, are associated with educational attainment at a correlation of .27 and with educational achievement such as school grades at .24; after accounting for sample ancestry, age at assessment, and education measure, these estimates rose to .29 and .50. Only 15% of estimates came from samples of non-European ancestry.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

A meta-analysis of international studies finds a 24% correlation between education achievement, as measured by grades, and “polygenic scores that are person-specific aggregates of inherited DNA differences.”

How well do inherited DNA differences predict educational attainment and achievement?

Core argument: A multilevel meta-analysis of 20 estimates covering 314,757 individuals found polygenic scores associated with educational attainment at ρ = .27 (95% CI .22–.32), and with educational achievement at ρ = .24 (95% CI .18–.30) across 19 estimates and 83,788 individuals.

Recent advances in genomics make it possible to predict individual differences in education from polygenic scores that are person-specific aggregates of inherited DNA differences. Here, we systematically reviewed and meta-analyzed the strength of these DNA-based predictions for educational attainment (e.g., years spent in full-time education) and educational achievement (e.g., school grades). For educational attainment (k = 20, n = 16, Ntotal = 314,757), a multilevel meta-analysis showed an association with polygenic scores of ρ = .27 (95% CI from .22 to .32). For educational achievement (k = 19, n = 10, Ntotal = 83,788), the association was ρ = .24 (95% CI from .18 to .30). Eurocentric biases were evident with only 15% of estimates being reported in samples of non-European ancestry. After accounting for sample ancestry, age at assessment, and education measure, the meta-analytic estimates increased to ρ = .29 (95% CI from .24 to .33) for educational attainment and ρ = .50 (95% CI from .39 to .61) for educational achievement, indicative of large effect sizes.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. A multilevel meta-analysis of 20 estimates covering 314,757 individuals found polygenic scores associated with educational attainment at ρ = .27 (95% CI .22–.32), and with educational achievement at ρ = .24 (95% CI .18–.30) across 19 estimates and 83,788 individuals.
  2. After accounting for sample ancestry, age at assessment, and education measure, the meta-analytic estimates rose to ρ = .29 (95% CI .24–.33) for educational attainment and ρ = .50 (95% CI .39–.61) for educational achievement, described as large effect sizes.
  3. Eurocentric biases were evident in the reviewed literature, with only 15% of estimates reported in samples of non-European ancestry.

AI Summary. A multilevel meta-analysis of 254 studies with 6,984 participants finds music training does not significantly improve children's cognitive skills or academic performance, with an overall effect size near zero. The authors attribute apparent benefits to study design weaknesses such as the absence of random allocation and active control groups.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

Music training cognitive benefits debunked: Meta-analysis (n=6,984, 254 studies) shows zero effect size. Perceived gains (g=0.200) stem from study design flaws, not actual cognitive enhancement.

Does music training improve children's cognitive skills and academic performance?

Core argument: A multilevel meta-analysis of 254 studies covering 6,984 participants finds an overall effect size of about 0 for music training on children's cognitive skills and academic performance.

A comprehensive meta-analysis involving 6,984 participants across 254 studies reveals that music training does not significantly enhance cognitive skills or academic performance, with an overall effect size of 𝑔̅ ≈ 0. The analysis shows that any perceived benefits are largely due to study design flaws, such as lack of random allocation and non-active controls, which inflate effect sizes to 𝑔̅ ≈ 0.200. Bayesian analyses confirm these findings, indicating that music training's impact is negligible across various outcome measures, participant ages, and training durations. The study underscores that optimism about music training's cognitive benefits is empirically unfounded, highlighting the need for rigorous experimental designs in future research.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. A multilevel meta-analysis of 254 studies covering 6,984 participants finds an overall effect size of about 0 for music training on children's cognitive skills and academic performance.
  2. Studies lacking random allocation and using non-active control groups inflate the estimated benefit of music training to an effect size of about 0.200, according to the meta-analysis.
  3. Bayesian analyses in the meta-analysis indicate music training's impact is negligible across outcome measures, participant ages, and training durations, and the authors call for more rigorous experimental designs.

Core of paper, “…Music training has repeatedly been claimed to positively impact children’s cognitive skills and academic achievement (literacy and mathematics). This claim relies on the assumption that engaging in intellectually demanding activities fosters particular domain- general cognitive skills, or even general intelligence. The present meta-analytic review (N = 6,984, k = 254, m = 54) shows that this belief is incorrect. Once the quality of study design is controlled for, the overall effect of music training programs is null (𝑔̅≈ 0) and highly consistent across studies (τ2 ≈ 0). Results of Bayesian analyses employing distributional assumptions (informative priors) derived from previous research in cognitive training corroborate these conclusions. Small statistically significant overall effects are obtained only in those studies implementing no random allocation of participants and employing non-active controls (𝑔̅≈ 0.200, p <.001). Interestingly, music training is ineffective regardless of the type of outcome measure (e.g., verbal, non-verbal, speed-related, etc.), participants’ age, and duration of training. Furthermore, we note that, beyond meta-analysis of experimental studies, a considerable amount of cross-sectional evidence indicates that engagement in music has no impact on people’s non-music cognitive skills or academic achievement. We conclude that researchers’ optimism about the benefits of music training is empirically unjustified and stems from misinterpretation of the empirical data and, possibly, confirmation bias…”

Supporting Evidence

“…This meta-analysis - which includes 38 studies, 118 effect sizes, and 3,085 participants - found an overall effect of𝑑̅= 0.16. It also highlighted that the impact of music training on cognitive skills and academic performance was a function of the quality of the study’s experimental design. Specifically, the magnitude of the music-induced effects was significantly smaller (around zero) in those studies implementing active controls and random allocation of the participants to groups….”

“…The overall effect size of the RVE intercept model was𝑔̅= 0.184, SE = 0.041, 95% CI, m = 54, k = 254, df = 38.36, p <.001, τ2 = 0.041, I2 = 43.16%. Different values of within-study effect-size correlation (ρ) did not significantly affect the results (𝑔̅range 0.184- 0.185, τ2 = 0.041). The random-effect (RE) model (with Cheung & Chan’s correction) yielded very similar estimates:𝑔̅= 0.176, SE = 0.037, p <.001, τ2 = 0.033. Overall, the results showed a small and moderately heterogeneous overall effect of music training on cognitive and academic outcomes. The results were not affected by modeling choices (i.e., ρ values and procedure for modeling nested data)…. Baseline difference and Type of controls were the only two statistically significant moderators (p =.031 and p =.035, respectively) and accounted for part of the true heterogeneity (τ2 = 0.038, I2 = 34.87%). Age was not significant (p =.403), neither was Allocation (p =.518). No significant differences were found across the four broad groups of outcome measures (all ps ≥.624; Holm’s correction for multiple comparisons), nor across the more fine-grained categorization (eight levels, all ps ≥.362), and there was no difference between cognitive skills and measures of academic achievement (p =.981). Duration of training was not significant either (p =.266, p =.952, and p =.662 for hours, weeks, and sessions, respectively).

Cognitive and academic benefits of music training with children: A multilevel meta-analysis: Extended Excerpt Image 1

Giovanni Sala and Fernand Gobet, "Cognitive and academic benefits of music training with children: A multilevel meta-analysis,"Memory & Cognition, July 29, 2020, https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/s13421-020-01060-2

AI Summary. A meta-analysis of 142 effect sizes from 42 data sets covering over 600,000 participants finds that an additional year of education is associated with a gain of roughly 1 to 5 IQ points. The authors report this association across multiple cognitive abilities, across the lifespan, and in three quasi-experimental designs.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

Education boosts intelligence by 1-5 IQ points per year, according to a meta-analysis of 142 effect sizes from 42 data sets involving over 600,000 participants.

How much does an additional year of education raise IQ?

Core argument: A meta-analysis of 142 effect sizes from 42 data sets covering more than 600,000 participants finds an additional year of education is associated with a gain of roughly 1–5 IQ points.

A comprehensive meta-analysis of 142 effect sizes from 42 data sets involving over 600,000 participants reveals that an additional year of education is consistently associated with a gain of approximately 1 to 5 IQ points. This effect persists across various cognitive abilities and throughout the lifespan, highlighting education as a robust method for enhancing intelligence. The analysis utilized three quasi-experimental designs: control prior intelligence, policy change, and school-age cutoff, each demonstrating significant educational impacts on cognitive outcomes. For instance, the school-age cutoff design showed an average increase of 5.229 IQ points per additional year of education. These findings underscore the economic implications of investing in education as a means to boost cognitive skills, which are crucial for workforce productivity and economic growth.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. A meta-analysis of 142 effect sizes from 42 data sets covering more than 600,000 participants finds an additional year of education is associated with a gain of roughly 1–5 IQ points.
  2. The school-age cutoff design yielded an average increase of 5.229 IQ points per additional year of education, one of three quasi-experimental designs alongside control of prior intelligence and policy change, each showing significant educational effects on cognitive outcomes.
  3. The estimated education effect persists across various cognitive abilities and throughout the lifespan, underscoring the economic implications of investing in education to boost cognitive skills relevant to workforce productivity and economic growth.

Summery, “…Intelligence test scores and educational duration are positively correlated. This correlation could be interpreted in two ways: Students with greater propensity for intelligence go on to complete more education, or a longer education increases intelligence. We meta-analyzed three categories of quasi-experimental studies of educational effects on intelligence: those estimating education-intelligence associations after controlling for earlier intelligence, those using compulsory schooling policy changes as instrumental variables, and those using regression-discontinuity designs on school-entry age cutoffs. Across 142 effect sizes from 42 data sets involving over 600,000 participants,we found consistent evidence for beneficial effects of education on cognitive abilities of approximately 1 to 5 IQ points for an additional year of education.Moderator analyses indicated that the effects persisted across the life span and were present on all broad categories of cognitive ability studied. Education appears to be the most consistent, robust, and durable method yet to be identified for raising intelligence….”

Stuart Ritchie and Elliot Tucker-Drob, "How Much Does Education Improve Intelligence? A Meta-Analysis,"Psychological Science, 2018, https://labs.la.utexas.edu/tucker-drob/files/2019/08/Ritchie-Tucker-Drob-2018-Psych-Science-How-Much-Does-Education-Improve-Intelligence.pdf

“….Table 2 shows the results from each study design after the inclusion of multiple moderators. We included as many moderators as possible for each design, though we chose to include the “achievement” categorization of the outcome test for the school-age-cutoff design (instead of the alternative categorization involving composite, fluid, and crystallized tests, which we used for the other designs) because it had such a substantial effect in the single-moderator model. Including multiple moderators reduced the τ statistic—to a larger degree for the control-prior-intelligence design than for the others— though significant heterogeneity remained in all cases. The moderators that were individually significant (e.g., age in the control-prior-intelligence design or achievement tests in the school-age-cutoff design) were also significant in the multiple-moderator model, indicating that their effects were incremental of the other moderators that we included….”

“…We tested whether studies that included only male participants showed a differential educational effect. This was not the case for control prior intelligence (effect for the 2 male-only estimates: 2.261 IQ points, SE = 0.897, p =.012; effect for 24 mixed-sex estimates: 1.027 IQ points, SE = 0.110, p = 6.79×10−21; difference SE = 0.905, p =.173), or for policy change (effect for the 8 male-only estimates: 1.683 IQ points, SE = 0.507, p =.001; effect for 22 mixed-sex estimates: 2.215 IQ points, SE = 0.788, p =.005; difference SE = 0.941, p =.572). There were no male-only school-age-cutoff studies….”

Multiple moderators.

“….Splitting the outcome cognitive tests into three broad categories—composite, fluid, and crystallized tests—we tested whether the category moderated effect sizes. For the control-prior-intelligence design, there were stronger educational impacts on composite tests (1.876 IQ points, SE = 0.467, p = 5.94×10−05) than on fluid tests (0.836 points, SE = 0.097, p =.152), and the difference between composite and fluid was significant (1.039 points, SE = 0.496, p =.036).There was only one crystallized outcome test for the control-prior- intelligence design (1.893 points, SE = 0.348, p = 5.34×10−08), so we did not include it in the moderator comparison here. For the policy-change design, there were significant effects for both composite (2.314 IQ points, SE = 0.869, p =.008) and fluid (2.272 points, SE = 0.765, p =.003) but not crystallized (1.012 points, SE = 1.125, p =.368) tests; however, the effects on the three different categories were not significantly different from one another (all difference p values >.35). Finally, for the school-age-cutoff design, there were significant effects of a year of education on composite (6.534 points, SE = 2.433, p =.007), fluid (5.104 points, SE = 0.621, p = 2.05×10−16), and crystallized (5.428 points, SE = 0.170, p = 1.04×10−223) tests; there were, however, no significant differences between effect sizes across outcome types (difference p values >.5). We then split the outcome tests into “achievement” tests versus “other” tests. There was only one achievement test in the control-prior-intelligence design, so we did not run this analysis. For policy change, there was no significant difference in the educational effect on the 7 achievement tests (2.760 IQ points, SE = 0.968, p =.004) versus the 23 other tests (1.784 points, SE = 0.553, p =.001; difference SE = 1.011, p =.334). However, for school-age cutoff, which had the largest proportion of achievement tests (38 of the 86 tests were classed as achievement tests), achievement tests showed a substantially and significantly larger educational effect (6.231 points, SE = 0.339, p = 2.85×10−75) than other tests (3.839 points, SE = 0.412, p = 1.11×10−20; difference SE = 0.371, p = 1.19×10−10)….”

Male-only studies.

Outcome test category.

“…Figure 1 shows the effect sizes in the first two study designs as a function of the participants’ mean age at the outcome test. For the control- prior-intelligence studies, outcome age was a significant moderator: The effect size of education declined by −0.026 IQ points per year of age (SE = 0.012, p =.029). At the youngest age (18 years) the effect size of having had an additional year of education was 2.154 IQ points, whereas at the oldest age (83 years) the effect size was 0.485 IQ points. This effect was smaller but still significant if the largest effect size (> 3 IQ points for an additional year) was excluded (−0.011 IQ points per year of age, SE = 0.005, p =.018). There was no significant moderating effect of age at outcome for the policy-change studies (0.014 IQ points per year, SE = 0.022, p =.543): The effect at the youngest age (18 years; 1.690 IQ points) was not significantly different from the effect at the oldest age (71 years; 2.413 IQ points). There was comparatively little variation in the age at the outcome test for the school-age- cutoff design (SD = 1.6 years; see Table 1); there was no significant age moderation effect (−0.027 points per year, SE = 0.399, p =.947)….”

“…. For the policy-change design, we tested whether the age at which the educational policy change produced an increment in compulsory schooling moderated the intervention effect. This was not the case: The effect size increased by a nonsignificant 0.038 IQ points per year of age at the intervention (SE = 0.228, p =.867). The meta-regression model implied that at the youngest intervention age (7.5 years), the effect size was 1.765 IQ points, and at the oldest (19 years) it was 2.204 IQ points….”

Age at outcome test.

“…For the control-prior-intelligence design, we tested whether the age at which the participants had taken the initial (control) cognitive test, or the gap between this early test and the outcome test, moderated the effect size. The age at the early test, which did not vary substantially (see Table 1) was not significantly related to the effect size (−0.024 IQ points per year, SE = 0.064, p =.706). For the youngest early-test age (10 years), the meta-regression model indicated that the effect size of 1 additional year of education was 1.243 IQ points; for the oldest (16 years), the effect size was 1.099 IQ points. Conversely, the time lag between the tests was a significant moderator of the effect size (−0.031 IQ points per year, SE = 0.015, p =.033). This meta-regression indicated that at the smallest age gap (5 years), the effect size was 2.398 IQ points, whereas for the largest age gap (72.44 years), the effect size was a substantially smaller 0.317 IQ points. Note that this age gap is almost fully confounded with the age at the out- come test (r =.988), assessed as a moderator below….”

Age at intervention.

Age at early test and time lag between tests.

“…We analyzed results from the three most prominent quasi-experimental methods for testing the effects of education on intelligence. We defined intelligence as the score on a cognitive test; see below for consideration of how the test scores might relate to the underlying psychological processes. Each method implements a different approach to minimize effects stemming from selection processes. Full meta-analytic inclusion criteria are reported below, but first we describe each of the three designs, providing a canonical example of each..…. The first research design, which we label control prior intelligence, is a longitudinal study in which cognitive testing data are collected before and after variation in the duration of education. This allows the relation between education and the second test to be adjusted for by each participant’s earlier ability level. An example of this design is the study by Clouston et al. (2012), who analyzed data from three large U.S. and UK cohort studies, all of which had both an adolescent and a midlife cognitive test. Results indicated that completing a university education was linked to higher midlife cognitive ability, above and beyond adolescent intelligence….…The second design, policy change, relies on changes in educational duration that are, by all accounts, exogenous to the characteristics of the individuals. An example of this design is the study by Brinch and Galloway (2012), who used large-scale data from a 1960s educational reform in Norway. This reform increased compulsory education by 2 years; critically, it was staggered across municipalities in the country. This allowed the researchers to estimate the effect of an additional year of school on a later intelligence test, taken by males at entry to military service as part of Norway’s universal military draft. Under the assumption that the policy change affected intelligence only via increasing years of schooling, the authors used an instrumental-variables analysis to estimate the effect of 1 year of schooling on intelligence at approximately 3.7 points on a standard IQ scale (M = 100, SD = 15 in the population)….…The third design takes advantage of a school-age cutoff. These studies use regression-discontinuity analysis to leverage the fact that school districts implement a date-of-birth cutoff for school entry. The first study to use this method was by Baltes and Reinert (1969), but the most highly cited example is by Cahan and Cohen (1989), who, in a sample of over 12,000 children across three grades of the Israeli school system (between the ages of approximately 10-12 years), found that schooling exerted positive effects on all of 12 tests covering a variety of cognitive domains. These educational effects were around twice the effect of a year of age. The strict assumptions of this method are some- times not fully met (Cliffordson, 2010); methodological issues are discussed in more detail below….”

Their Evidence

“…In three separate unconditional random-effects meta- analytic models (one for each study design), we estimated the effect of 1 additional year of education on cognitive outcomes. For all three study designs, there was a significant effect of 1 additional year of education. For control prior intelligence, the effect was 1.197 IQ points (SE = 0.203, p = 3.84×10−09); for policy change, it was 2.056 IQ points (SE = 0.583, p = 4.23×10−04); and for school-age cutoff, it was 5.229 IQ points (SE = 0.530, p = 6.33×10−23). An overall model including all estimates from all three designs found an average effect size of 3.394 IQ points for 1 year of education (SE = 0.503, p = 1.55×10−11)….”

Types of Studies They Looked At

AI Summary. Genome-wide polygenic scores indicate European populations after the Neolithic period show increases in height, educational attainment, and intelligence scores, alongside decreases in scores for unipolar depression. The authors associate this shift from relative stagnation to accelerated evolutionary change with the spread of agriculture and animal domestication.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

European populations experienced significant evolutionary changes after the Neolithic period, notably an increase in height and intelligence scores, as evidenced by genome-wide polygenic scores.

Did the spread of agriculture accelerate human evolution of complex traits?

Core argument: Genome-wide polygenic scores indicate that European populations increased in height, educational attainment, and intelligence scores from the Neolithic onwards, while scores for traits related to unipolar depression decreased.

After the Neolithic period, European populations experienced significant evolutionary changes, notably an increase in height and intelligence scores, as evidenced by genome-wide polygenic scores. This period marked a shift from relative stagnation to accelerated evolution, driven by the spread of agriculture and animal domestication. The genetic data show a clear increase in educational attainment and intelligence from the Neolithic onwards, while traits related to unipolar depression decreased. These changes highlight the rapid pace of human evolution and its impact on physiological traits, underscoring the influence of cultural and lifestyle shifts on human development.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Genome-wide polygenic scores indicate that European populations increased in height, educational attainment, and intelligence scores from the Neolithic onwards, while scores for traits related to unipolar depression decreased.
  2. European populations shifted from relative stagnation to accelerated evolution after the Neolithic, a change attributed to the spread of agriculture and animal domestication.

We built genome-wide polygenic scores for heritable traits, including height, body mass index, lipoprotein concentrations, cardiovascular disease, and intelligence, using summary statistics of genome-wide association studies in Europeans. Subsequently, we applied these scores to the genomes of ancient European populations. Our results revealed that after the Neolithic, European populations experienced an increase in height and intelligence scores, decreased their skin pigmentation, while the risk for coronary artery disease increased through a genetic trajectory favoring low HDLconcentrations. These results are a reflection of the continuous evolutionary processes in humans and highlight the impact that the Neolithic revolution had on our lifestyle and health.We used ancient DNA (aDNA) data of 827 ancient individuals from Western Eurasia, which were publicly available and aggregated into a database released 22 February 2019, by the David Reich lab (version 37.2) The aDNA data was used in conjunction with DNA data of 250 randomly selected modern individuals from Western Europe, which were downloaded from 1000G database Using GWAS summary statistics from GWAS catalogue and United Kingdom Biobank, which can be seen in Supplementary Table S1, we calculated PRS for each individual for various traits respectively, using a QTL p-value threshold of 10-6, in 250 kb windows. Multiple thresholds were further tested for assuring the robustness of the findings. We supplemented the effect of missing variants in a sample with the average of the entire population. We then scaled the PRS distribution to have a range of 1 to −1 before correlating them with the carbon-dated sample age. One general observation is the existence of a clear difference in the trajectories of the various traits before and after the Neolithic revolution: few changes are seen between the Early Upper Paleolithic until the Neolithic period, with a general acceleration of the evolutionary processes thereafter. Interestingly, while the period between the Early Upper Paleolithic and the Neolithic is characterized by stagnation or slight decrease in PRS related to intelligence, the genetic data show a clear increase in the scores for educational attainment, intelligence, and fluid intelligence from the Neolithic onwards, while the traits related with unipolar depression tend to decrease from that era on (Figures 3A,B). The most significant differences can be observed comparing the pre-Neolithic and Neolithic groups, as well as the post-Neolithic and modern groups, whereas the period between the Neolithic and post-Neolithic shows a very constant distribution of PRS scores (Figure 3C).In conclusion, using genetic models applied to ancient genomes, we describe important changes that have taken place in the physiological traits of modern Homo sapiens populations living in Europe since the Early Upper Paleolithic. Although the exact extent of the evolutionary changes Europeans underwent remain unclear, based on these genetic trajectories we can see that while the first 40,000 years in Europe represented a period of relative stagnation in the evolution of these traits, the spread of Neolithic populations and of the cultural complex associated with agriculture and animal domestication has led to important changes in height, weight, skin color, an increase in intellectual attainment, as well as in cholesterol metabolism and the risk for cardiovascular diseases. These new insights put into light the processes that have shaped human physiology since the migration of modern humans throughout Europe.

Yunus Kuijpers, Jorge Domínguez-Andrés, Olivier Bakker, Manoj Kumar Gupta, Martin Grasshoff, Cheng-Jian Xu, Leo A.B. Joosten, Jaume Bertranpetit, Mihai G. Netea and Yang Li, “Evolutionary Trajectories Of Complex Traits In European Populations Of Modern Humans,” Frontiers in Genetics,March 28, 2022, https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fgene.2022.833190/full

AI Summary. Genetics research finds that non-cognitive skills such as motivation and resilience contribute to educational attainment alongside cognitive ability, with one study estimating a genetic correlation of 0.31 between non-cognitive skills and IQ. Genes associated with conditions including bipolar disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder are linked to higher non-cognitive skills, potentially offsetting negative associations with IQ.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

Research by @slatestarcodex suggests genes linked to mental illness may enhance non-cognitive skills, crucial for educational attainment & household income. A genetic correlation of r = 0.31 btw non-cognitive skills & IQ highlights complex genetic architecture underlying education.

Do genes linked to mental illness also raise non-cognitive skills?

Core argument: Demange et al. estimate a genetic correlation of r = 0.31 between non-cognitive skills and IQ, suggesting that traits such as motivation and resilience contribute substantially to educational attainment alongside cognitive ability.

Recent genetics research indicates that genes associated with certain mental illnesses may enhance non-cognitive skills, which are crucial for educational attainment and indirectly linked to higher household income. While cognitive skills are more directly tied to IQ, non-cognitive skills such as motivation and resilience also significantly contribute to educational success. A study by Demange et al. found a genetic correlation of r = 0.31 between non-cognitive skills and IQ, suggesting these skills play a substantial role in education. Interestingly, genes linked to conditions like bipolar disorder and OCD may boost non-cognitive skills, potentially offsetting some negative impacts on IQ. This genetic interplay suggests that while mental illness genes can decrease IQ, they might offer compensatory benefits in educational contexts, ultimately influencing economic outcomes like income and decision-making. These findings highlight the complex genetic architecture underlying education and economic success, offering new insights for policymakers and economists.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Demange et al. estimate a genetic correlation of r = 0.31 between non-cognitive skills and IQ, suggesting that traits such as motivation and resilience contribute substantially to educational attainment alongside cognitive ability.
  2. Genes linked to bipolar disorder and OCD may boost non-cognitive skills, which the research suggests could partly offset the negative effects those genes have on IQ.
  3. Non-cognitive skills are indirectly linked to higher household income, and the research presents education's genetic architecture as relevant to economic outcomes including income and decision-making.

Scott Alexander reports on new genetics research that suggests some of the genes associated with mental illness may have compensatory benefits, "...But genes for some other conditions increase non-cognitive skills related to educational attainment. Bipolar disorder, fine…manic creativity hard work. OCD, fine, it’s probably on a spectrum with OCPD which is on a spectrum with regular perfectionism. Autism, fine, probably a lot of Math PhDs. But the big shock here is schizophrenia. As of last time I checked, the leading hypothesis was that schizophrenia genes were just really bad, evolutionary detritus that we hadn’t quite managed to weed out. And although they definitely decrease IQ, they seem to be good in other ways. Not with certainty: the correction for false discovery rate kills a lot of the effect (though this is the question I would have been most interested in before reading these results, so maybe I can ignore that?). But there’s at least a faint signal here….At some point, some geneticists just did the hard thing and found some actual genes for actual intelligence, separate from educational attainment. And if you have both the educational attainment genes and the intelligence genes, you can subtract the one from the other to find the non-intelligence-related genes that affect educational attainment in other ways. That's the thought process behind Investigating the genetic architecture of noncognitive skills using GWAS-by-subtraction, by Demange et al...They admit not doing a perfect job. Their genetic measure of non-cognitive skills (ie factors that affect educational attainment other than intelligence) was still correlated at r = 0.31 with IQ (higher than most things in social sciences ever correlate with anything). So take their results as directionally rather than exactly true. Still, what did they find? Unsurprisingly, both sets of skills contribute to educational attainment (that’s the point), and cognitive skills contribute more to IQ (that’s also the point). I was pretty surprised by how much more specifically “self-reported math ability” isolates cognitive ability compared to “highest math class taken”, but I guess people are good at self-assessment. But the real fun is Figure 4: This is correlation between the genes for cognitive/non-cognitive skills related to educational attainment, and the genes for something else (eg household income). Note that these are genetic correlations, so they’re not looking at your actual household income, they’re looking at the genes that would cause you to have a high household income. This is probably better since it avoids lots of possible confounders...."

Scott Alexander, "Non-Cognitive Skills For Educational Attainment Suggest Benefits Of Mental Illness Genes," Astral Codex Ten, November 3, 2021, https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/non-cognitive-skills-for-educational

Non-Cognitive Skills For Educational Attainment Suggest Benefits Of Mental Illness Genes

Suppose you want to study the genetics of intelligence. You probably want a sample size in the six digits, and you can't make a six digit number of people sit down and take IQ tests. Also, whenever you say "genetics" and "intelligence" in the same sentence, an angry mob shows up at your door. One solution is to switch to a more popular / less stressful line of work, like Mafia snitch or al-Qaeda second-in-command. But another solution is to use educational attainment.

"Educational attainment" means how far you got in school - did you graduate high school? Get halfway through college? Go to grad school? It's a nice simple number that everyone already knows, and studies show it's closely correlated with intelligence. This is the most common way people investigate cognitive genetics, and if you hear someone talk offhanded about finding "genes for intelligence", they probably found genes for educational attainment.

Educational attainment is closely correlated with intelligence, but not perfectly correlated. How far you go in school depends not just on your IQ, but on other skills: how hard-working and motivated you are, how well you can cope with adversity - and arguably also less desirable qualities, like whether you so desperately seek societal approval that you're willing to throw away your entire twenties on a PhD with no job prospects at the end of it. "Genes for educational attainment" will be a combination of genes for intelligence, and genes for this other stuff.

At some point, some geneticists just did the hard thing and found some actual genes for actual intelligence, separate from educational attainment. And if you have both the educational attainment genes and the intelligence genes, you can subtract the one from the other to find the non-intelligence-related genes that affect educational attainment in other ways. That's the thought process behind Investigating the genetic architecture of noncognitive skills using GWAS-by-subtraction, by Demange et al (the "al" includes some researchers whose work has featured here before, like Paige Harden, Elliot Tucker-Drob, and Abdel Abdellaoiu).

They admit not doing a perfect job. Their genetic measure of non-cognitive skills (ie factors that affect educational attainment other than intelligence) was still correlated at r = 0.31 with IQ (higher than most things in social sciences ever correlate with anything). So take their results as directionally rather than exactly true. Still, what did they find?

Non-Cognitive Skills For Educational Attainment Suggest Benefits Of Mental Illness Genes: Extended Excerpt Image 1


Unsurprisingly, both sets of skills contribute to educational attainment (that’s the point), and cognitive skills contribute more to IQ (that’s also the point). I was pretty surprised by how much more specifically “self-reported math ability” isolates cognitive ability compared to “highest math class taken”, but I guess people are good at self-assessment.

But the real fun is Figure 4:

Non-Cognitive Skills For Educational Attainment Suggest Benefits Of Mental Illness Genes: Extended Excerpt Image 2


This is correlation between the genes for cognitive/non-cognitive skills related to educational attainment, and the genes for something else (eg household income). Note that these are genetic correlations, so they’re not looking at your actual household income, they’re looking at the genes that would cause you to have a high household income. This is probably better since it avoids lots of possible confounders.

Both cognitive and non-cognitive skills increase your income a lot, no surprise there. Both sets of skills improve your lifespan (probably more educated people are better at judging health advice - get your COVID vaccine!) and prevent you from making bad decisions like teenage pregnancy, smoking, or excessive drinking.

The Big 5 personality factors are yet more evidence for stereotype accuracy: the intelligent people are more introverted, more disagreeable, and less conscientious; the people who do well for reasons other than intelligence are more likely to be extraverted, agreeable, and diligent. Both cognitive and non-cognitive skills are negatively correlated with neuroticism, which is not what I would have expected.

And then there’s mental illness.

I have been saying for years that I think some of the genes for some mental illnesses must have compensatory benefits. Everyone else said that was dumb, they’re mostly selected against and decrease IQ. But here we get a pretty clear picture of where this is and isn’t true.

Depression is just bad. I strongly recommend not having it. Don’t even have any risk genes, if you can avoid it. All of you people trying to come up with clever evolutionary benefits for depression, I still think you’re wrong, and so does the genetic correlation with cognitive and non-cognitive aspects of educational attainment.

ADHD is also just bad here. This doesn’t entirely match my previous beliefs; I think it’s helpful with a certain kind of high-stress task switching. But we can’t blame this study for not picking that up; it’s just using the giant bucket “non-cognitive skills that affect your ability to stay in school”, of which ADHD is definitely one and definitely net bad. I suspect that there are different forms of the syndrome that are vs. aren’t associated with low intelligence (and maybe some associated with high intelligence), but this is total speculation and this study tells us nothing about this one way or the other, except that it’s correlated with lower intelligence on net.

But genes for some other conditions increase non-cognitive skills related to educational attainment. Bipolar disorder, fine, something something manic creativity hard work. OCD, fine, it’s probably on a spectrum with OCPD which is on a spectrum with regular perfectionism. Autism, fine, probably a lot of Math PhDs.

But the big shock here is schizophrenia. As of last time I checked, the leading hypothesis was that schizophrenia genes were just really bad, evolutionary detritus that we hadn’t quite managed to weed out. And although they definitely decrease IQ, they seem to be good in other ways. Not with certainty: the correction for false discovery rate kills a lot of the effect (though this is the question I would have been most interested in before reading these results, so maybe I can ignore that?). But there’s at least a faint signal here.

I may write some future posts going down the very weird rabbit holes this result opens up.

AI Summary. The study estimates that a 1 standard deviation increase in the quality of the parental environment raises IQ by about 2.83 points, with the parental environment accounting for 4% of the variance in full-scale IQ at age 15. Genetic factors account for 42% of IQ variance in adulthood.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

A 1SD increase in parental environment quality boosts IQ by ~2.83 points, highlighting the economic benefits of investing in family environments. @MattMcGue

How much do parental environment and genes each shape adult IQ?

Core argument: A 1 SD increase in parental environment quality is associated with an IQ gain of about 2.83 points in the study of adoptive and biological families with 30-year-old offspring.

The study highlights that a 1 standard deviation (SD) increase in the quality of the parental environment can enhance IQ by approximately 2.83 points, emphasizing the economic implications of investing in family environments. The biometric decomposition of variance shows that the parental environment contributes 4% to the variance in full-scale IQs at age 15, with a standard deviation of 14.2 for adopted offspring. Despite the modest impact of the parental environment, genetic factors remain predominant, accounting for 42% of IQ variance in adulthood. These findings suggest that while genetic influences are significant, targeted improvements in parental environments could yield measurable benefits in cognitive outcomes, potentially influencing workforce productivity and economic growth.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. A 1 SD increase in parental environment quality is associated with an IQ gain of about 2.83 points in the study of adoptive and biological families with 30-year-old offspring.
  2. Biometric decomposition attributes 4% of the variance in full-scale IQ at age 15 to the parental environment, with a standard deviation of 14.2 among adopted offspring.
  3. Genetic factors account for 42% of IQ variance in adulthood, exceeding the contribution of the parental environment.

Emily Willoughby, Matt McGue, William Iacono and James Lee, "Genetic and environmental contributions to IQ in adoptive and biological families with 30-year-old offspring," Intelligence, September/October 2021
https://www.gwern.net/docs/iq/2021-willoughby.pdf

Genetic and environmental contributions to IQ in adoptive and biological families with 30-year-old offspring: Extended Excerpt Image 1


The sample:"...The ethnic composition of offspring in this sample is additionally unique; while 95% of parents and biological offspring are of non- Hispanic white European ancestry, 21% of the adoptive offspring are white, 66% are Asian, and 13% are of other ethnicities (McGue et al., 2007; Miller et al., 2012). McGue et al. (2007) reported minimal ethnicity effects in the SIBS sample at intake, which we largely replicate in the current follow-up assessment. While rearing family socioeconomicstatus and polygenic scores were both moderately higher among Asian offspring (Cohen’s d = 0.36-0.46; p <.01), no measure of cognitive ability differed significantly between offspring of different ethnicities. See SI Table S6 for these and other comparisons, along with a discussion of their relevance...."

Genetic and environmental contributions to IQ in adoptive and biological families with 30-year-old offspring: Extended Excerpt Image 2


Results:"...Measures of full-scale IQ taken at follow-up 3 were moderatelycorrelated over time for both offspring and parents (all p <.001). For offspring, ICAR-16 scores (follow-up 3) correlated with intake Total IQ at r = 0.46; for parents, this correlation was also r = 0.46. The moderate size of these correlations partially reflects the approximately 17-year gap between testing sessions, especially for offspring who were of adolescent age at intake assessment (see, e.g., Hoekstra, Bartels, & Boomsma, 2007), but are nevertheless within the range reported by Condon and Revelle (2014) for the ICAR-16 and various measures of general ability. Offspring Vocabulary scores taken at intake correlated with their Vocabulary scores at follow-up 3 at r = 0.53. SI Tables S8—S10 show full correlation tables between these and other intake measures of IQ for each sub-sample of individuals. At intake, parent-offspring correlations were significant and moderately sized only in biological families, with two exceptions (Table 2). Picture Completion showed very low correlations between all relatives except father and biological child (r =.30). Vocabulary was an exception in that the correlations between adoptive relatives were also moderate in size. At follow-up 3, familial correlations for the ICAR-16 are largely consistent with the expected patterns of correlations between biological and adoptive relatives for a heritable trait little affected by shared environment (Table 2). The correlations between biological relatives are significant and moderate in size, whereas those between adoptive relatives are consistently smaller. Vocabulary, by contrast, shows surprisingly persistent correlations between both adoptive and biological relatives in adulthood. The correlations specifically between parent andoffspring are displayed in Fig. 2….”

Genetic and environmental contributions to IQ in adoptive and biological families with 30-year-old offspring: Extended Excerpt Image 3

Bottomline, “.. Our biometric decomposition of variance is consistent with this figure: the parental environment contributing 4% of the variance in full scale IQs at age ~15 (Table 3), with a standard deviation of 14.2 for fullscale IQ in adopted offspring, indicates that a 1-SD increase in the quality of the parental environment would increase IQ by approximately 2.83 points (i.e., 14.2.04 √; Burks, 1938)...."

Study published in Intelligence finds that adoptive parents had no impact on their (adopted) children's adult intelligence, "...While adoption studies have provided key insights into the influence of the familial environment on IQ scores of adolescents and children, few have followed adopted offspring long past the time spent living in the family home. To improve confidence about the extent to which shared environment exerts enduring effects on IQ, we estimated genetic and environmental effects on adulthood IQ in a unique sample of 486 biological and adoptive families. These families, tested previously on measures of IQ when offspring averaged age 15, were assessed a second time nearly two decades later (M offspring age = 32 years). We estimated the proportions of the variance in IQ attributable to environmentally mediated effects of parental IQs, sibling-specific shared environment, and gene-environment covariance to be 0.01, 0.04, and 0.03 respectively; these components jointly accounted for 8% of the IQ variance in adulthood. The heritability was estimated to be 0.42. Together, these findings provide further evidence for the predominance of genetic influences on adult intelligence over any other systematic source of variation...."

Ed Comment:Here’s the problem with this study: a shocking 66% of the children were Asian while 95% of the parents were white. Which white parents are eager to adopt Asian children? …the smart ones that really want smart children. so this study is likely to find more relation with parents IQ then actually exists but for selection bias.

Note their takeaway on twin studies, "...A long history of twin and family studies has found that between 50 and 80% of variance in IQ is associated with genetic factors in industrialized countries, with perhaps 50% attributable to additive genetic factors alone..."

AI Summary. Analysis of roughly 9,000 children of women in a long-running US survey finds that small increases with age in socioeconomic status effects on cognitive and achievement test scores disappear once mother's ability is taken into account. The authors conclude socioeconomic status effects are minimal net of parental and child ability, with no evidence of cumulating advantage.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database

Research by @GaryMarks in @Intelligence finds SES effects on children’s test scores are minimal when net of parental & child’s abilities, indicating no cumulative socioeconomic advantage. This suggests SES impact is more genetic in origin.

Do socioeconomic advantages accumulate as children age?

Core argument: Using NLSY79 mothers' children (N ≈ 9,000; ~27,000 observations), the analysis finds that small increases with age in socioeconomic status (SES) effects on cognitive and achievement test scores are largely explained by parental and prior abilities.

Analysis of data from NLSY79 mothers' children (N ≈ 9000, Obs ≈ 27,000) reveals that while SES [socioeconomic status] effects on cognitive and achievement domains show small increases with age, these are largely explained by parental and prior abilities. Regression analyses indicate that SES effects do not increase with age when accounting for mother's ability, suggesting that observed SES effects are spurious. Mother's ability correlates at 0.26 with digit memory and between 0.4 and 0.5 with other domains, while SES correlates at 0.62 with mother's ability. The study concludes that SES effects on children's test scores are minimal when net of parental and child's abilities, indicating no cumulative socioeconomic advantage. This suggests that the perceived impact of SES is more genetic in origin, emphasizing the role of inherited cognitive abilities over environmental factors in educational outcomes.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Using NLSY79 mothers' children (N ≈ 9,000; ~27,000 observations), the analysis finds that small increases with age in socioeconomic status (SES) effects on cognitive and achievement test scores are largely explained by parental and prior abilities.
  2. Mother's ability correlates 0.26 with digit memory and 0.4–0.5 with other domains, while SES correlates 0.62 with mother's ability, and SES effects no longer increase with age once mother's ability is accounted for.
  3. The authors conclude that SES effects on children's test scores are minimal net of parental and child ability, indicating no cumulative socioeconomic advantage and suggesting the perceived SES impact is more genetic in origin.

Steady as she goes, "Studies that investigate the effects of socioeconomic background (SES) on student achievement tend to find stronger SES effects with age, although there is much inconsistency between studies. There is also a large academic literature on cumulative advantage arguing that SES inequalities increase as children age, a type of Matthew Effect. This study analysing data from the children of NLSY79 mothers (N ≈ 9000, Obs ≈ 27,000) investigates the relationship of SES by children's age for two cognitive domains (Peabody Picture Vocabulary test and digit span memory) and three achievement domains (reading comprehension, reading recognition and math). There are small increases in the SES-test score correlations for several domains, but there are more substantial increases in the test score correlations with mother's ability and prior ability. Regression analyses found linear increases in SES effects for all domains except digit memory. However, when considering mother's ability, the substantially reduced SES effects did not increase with children's age. Much of the effects of SES on children's domain scores are accounted for by mother's ability. The effects of prior ability also increase with age and SES effects are small. Therefore, there is no evidence for cumulative socioeconomic advantage for these domains. Generally, increases in SES effects on children's cognitive development and student achievement are likely to be spurious because of the importance of parents' abilities and their transmission from parents to children..."
Takeaway, "...The main conclusion from this study is that the increase in the SES effects on cognitive development and student achievement as children grow older observed in these data is spurious, confounded by parental and child's abilities. Increases in SES effects with age for some domains disappear with the inclusion of mother's ability and mother's ability age interaction terms, or with analogous measures of prior ability. Net of mother's and child's abilities, SES effects on children's test scores are small, so changes in its effects with age are unimportant..."
Evidence

“…Five childhood outcomes are investigated. Two are cognitive: the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT) and the Wechsler digit memory span scores; and three are achievement measures: the Peabody Individual Achievement Tests (PIAT) for reading comprehension, reading recognition, and math. At ages 3 and 4, children were tested only by theppVT, at age 5 only by theppVT and PIAT math, and at age 6 in all domains but digit memory. From ages 7 to 12, children were tested in all domains, and from age 13 to 15 only in the two PIAT reading domains and PIAT math…Mother's cognitive ability is measured by AFQT score from parts of the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery; a special survey administered in 1980 to NLSY79 respondents. The raw AFQT score in the NLSY79 data is the sum of scores in the arithmetic reasoning, word knowledge and paragraph comprehension subtests and one-half of the score in the numeric operations subtest…At ages 3 and 4 there were onlyppVT items, so the multiple-domain factor was the same as the single-domain factor. Between ages 7 and 12 when students were tested in all 5 domains, the variation accounted for by g increased from 25% to 37% consistent with the increasing heritability of cognitive ability with age. If theppVT and digit memory items are excluded, the percentage of variance explained by the principal factor increases by about 10 percentage points. Pooling all the data, mother's ability correlates at 0.26 with digit memory and between 0.4 and 0.5 with the other four domains. Cognitive ability, g, correlates most strongly withppVT scores (r = 0.78), most weakly with digit memory (r = 0.47) and between 0.66 and 0.73 with the other domains. Mother's ability and g correlate at 0.46 consistent with studies cited earlier that have reported intergenerational correlations for ability.Family SES correlates at 0.62 with mother's ability which is higher than Torres's estimate (Torres, 2013, p. 166). SES and g correlate at 0.41. The average correlation between ability and prior ability is 0.6 (Table A4). The correlations of ability and prior ability were generally higher at older ages (Table A5) again consistent with the increasing heritability of cognitive ability….”

Results

“…children's age for the five domains. TheppVT (blue diamond, solid line) and math (purple triangle, long-dash short-dash line) show the highest correlations and digit memory (red squares, dashed line), the lowest correlations. For reading comprehension (green star, dotted line) there is dramatic increase in the SES-achievement correlation with age. There are shallower increases in the correlations with age for theppVT and math. For reading recognition (brown circle, short-dash dot short-dash line) there is an anomalous correlation (0.44) at age 5 but for older ages the correlations are stable at around 0.35. The correlations between SES and digit memory decline from ages 7 to 9 and then increase. So even without considering mother's or child's ability, the evidence for cumulating socioeconomic inequalities is not unequivocable. Fig. 2 presents the correlations between mother's ability (AFQT) score and test scores. There is a substantial increase in the correlation between mother's ability and reading comprehension with children's age. The AFQT correlations with theppVT, math and reading recognition show clear but smaller increases. For digit memory, the correlations increase between ages 8 and 12. The LOESS curves show largely linear or curvilinear relationships. The correlations between prior ability and children's test scores show clear increases with age for all five domains (Fig. 3). For theppVT, there is an anomalous very large correlation at age 6 (≈0.7) and very low rapidly until age 10 and then stabilizes. The correlations between prior ability and digit memory are weaker but also show an increase with age…”
No evidence for cumulating socioeconomic advantage. Ability explains increasing SES effects with age on children's domain test scores: Extended Excerpt Image 1

Gary Marks and Michael O'Connell, "No evidence for cumulating socioeconomic advantage. Ability explains increasing SES effects with age on children's domain test scores,"Intelligence, September/October 2021, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289621000660