AI Summary. The authors find no statistically significant evidence that $190bn in federal emergency K-12 school aid mitigated pandemic learning loss or raised district spending. Districts qualifying for additional funds saw local revenues fall by $907 per pupil over three years, about 8% of pre-pandemic average, roughly 80% from property taxes.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

Exploiting a discontinuity in K-12 public school districts’ qualification for Covid emergency funding (ESSR), Clemens et al find that the funds did not mitigate learning loss. To a large extent, local districts used them to lower property taxes.

Do federal emergency education grants reduce student learning loss?

Core argument: Districts crossing the 5% poverty cutoff for additional ESSER funds saw local revenues fall an estimated $907 per pupil over three years, about 8% of the pre-COVID average.

Emergency funding for K-12 public schools was an important component of recession spending packages during COVID, involving $190 billion in additional expenditure. We see no evidence that ESSER funds helped to mitigate learning loss, at least in the short run. We find no statistically significant evidence that districts increased expenditures in SY 2021 or SY 2022. We do find evidence that districts that qualified for additional ESSER funds had statistically significant reductions in local revenues that were in excess of their ESSER funds. This pass-through of federal funds may partially explain why ESSER had minimal impacts on learning loss for districts around the 5% poverty threshold. Our estimates suggest that over the three years, crossing the qualification cutoff for additional ESSER funds is associated with a $907 per pupil decrease in local revenues, or about 8% of the pre-COVID average. We show the decline in local revenues as an event study in Figure 3, which includes a flat pre-COVID trend in local revenues per pupil across the qualification threshold. In Table 5,Column 5 [], we can see that about 80% of the revenue decline came from decreases in revenues from property taxes, [which fell] by $718 per pupil across the 3 years. The findings apply specifically to districts in the neighborhood of the 5% poverty threshold for qualifying for additional ESSER funds.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Districts crossing the 5% poverty cutoff for additional ESSER funds saw local revenues fall an estimated $907 per pupil over three years, about 8% of the pre-COVID average.
  2. About 80% of that local revenue decline came from property taxes, which fell by $718 per pupil across the three years.
  3. The authors find no evidence that ESSER emergency K-12 funding, totaling $190 billion, mitigated learning loss in the short run, and no statistically significant increase in district expenditures in SY 2021 or SY 2022.

AI Summary. Local economic distress is associated with wider male-female gaps in educational attainment: men are 1–2% less likely than women to hold a high school diploma in the most prosperous places, versus 4–5% less likely in the most distressed places. In distressed counties, 53% of women but only 43% of men have at least some college education.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

American men in distressed counties are 24% less likely to be employed than their peers in prosperous counties, while women are 19% less likely. This is likely downstream from a widening gender gap in high school graduation rates in distressed counties.

Does local economic distress widen male-female gaps in educational attainment?

Core argument: In distressed counties, 53% of women have at least some college education versus 43% of men, a 10 percentage point difference, according to the Distressed Communities Index.

In our latest release of the Distressed Communities Index, we highlighted the very strong relationship between local economic distress and the gap in educational outcomes between men and women. Men in the most prosperous places are 1–2% less likely to have attained a high school diploma than women; men in mid-tier places are 2–3% less likely; and men in the most distressed places are 4–5% less likely. Nationally, 90% of women and 89% of men over 25 have a high school diploma — close to parity. But this relatively small gap in educational attainment is significantly larger in distressed places. When men and women with only a high school diploma, versus those with any college education, are separated out, the attainment gaps widen further. On average, 53% of women in distressed counties have received at least some college education, while only 43% of men have — a 10 percentage point difference.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. In distressed counties, 53% of women have at least some college education versus 43% of men, a 10 percentage point difference, according to the Distressed Communities Index.
  2. Men are 1–2% less likely than women to have attained a high school diploma in the most prosperous places, 2–3% less likely in mid-tier places, and 4–5% less likely in the most distressed places.
  3. Nationally, 90% of women and 89% of men over 25 hold a high school diploma, close to parity, but the gap is significantly larger in distressed places.

AI Summary. U.S. twelfth-graders' average math and reading scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress fell to their lowest levels on record, with math the worst since that test began in 2005 and reading below any point since 1992. The share rated proficient slid 2 percentage points to 35% in reading and 22% in math.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

New National Assessment of Educational Progress results show the share of American high school seniors who scored basic or above on national tests fell to the lowest level on record: 68% in reading and 55% in math.

Have U.S. twelfth-grade math and reading scores fallen to record lows?

Core argument: U.S. twelfth-graders' average math score was the worst since the current National Assessment of Educational Progress math test began in 2005, and their reading score fell below any point since that assessment started in 1992.

American high-school seniors’ scores on major math and reading tests fell to their lowest levels on record, according to results released Tuesday by the U.S. Education Department. Twelfth-graders’ average math score was the worst since the current test began in 2005, and reading was below any point since that assessment started in 1992. The share of 12th-graders who were proficient slid by 2 percentage points between 2019 and 2024—to 35% in reading and 22% in math. The results are from tests that are part of the National Assessment of Educational Progress, administered to tens of thousands of students in early 2024. In reading, two-thirds of seniors could determine the purpose of a persuasive essay, but only one in five was able to draw a conclusion from such an essay, supported by the text. In math, 60% of students deduced the population of an area using information on size and density, while just under half correctly turned a real-world scenario into an algebraic expression.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. U.S. twelfth-graders' average math score was the worst since the current National Assessment of Educational Progress math test began in 2005, and their reading score fell below any point since that assessment started in 1992.
  2. The share of U.S. 12th-graders scoring proficient fell 2 percentage points between 2019 and 2024, to 35% in reading and 22% in math, according to results released by the U.S. Education Department.
  3. In reading, two-thirds of seniors could determine the purpose of a persuasive essay but only one in five could draw a text-supported conclusion from it, while in math just under half converted a real-world scenario into an algebraic expression.

AI Summary. In a randomized trial, parents receiving $1,000 per month in unconditional cash for three years spent more on their children monthly and reported better parenting behaviors, such as closer supervision, than parents receiving $50 per month. The transfer had no meaningful effect on most educational outcomes, the home environment, child food security, homelessness, or parental satisfaction.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

A randomized experiment giving 1,000 parents an unconditional $1K/month over 3 years found essentially no differences in family outcomes; treated children showed no significant gains in well-being or education.

Do unconditional cash transfers improve children's outcomes?

Core argument: Parents randomly assigned a $1,000 per month unconditional cash transfer for three years spent more on their children monthly and reported better parenting behaviors, such as closer supervision, than parents receiving $50 per month.

Parents who were randomly selected to receive a $1,000 per month unconditional cash transfer for three years spent more on their children each month and reported better parenting behaviors (such as supervising their children more closely) compared to those randomized to receive $50 per month. The transfer did not have a meaningful effect on most educational outcomes measured in school administrative records, nor did it affect characteristics of the home environment, child food security, exposure to homelessness, or parental satisfaction. Figure A3 shows no significant effect of the transfer on the home environment overall in any year, nor on the probability a child is unhoused. It appears that child food insecurity is [actually] significantly worse for transfer recipients in the third year of the transfer and close to zero in the first two years, [though] this third year effect on child food security does not remain significant after adjusting inference for False Discovery Rates due to repeated testing. Among adult participants, food security improves significantly as a result of the transfer in the first year but worsens over time. Treated families were more likely to move, [but] we did not detect changes in most measures of neighborhood quality,

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Parents randomly assigned a $1,000 per month unconditional cash transfer for three years spent more on their children monthly and reported better parenting behaviors, such as closer supervision, than parents receiving $50 per month.
  2. The $1,000 monthly transfer had no meaningful effect on most educational outcomes in school administrative records, nor on the home environment, child food security, exposure to homelessness, or parental satisfaction.
  3. Adult food security improved significantly in the first year of the transfer but worsened over time, and child food insecurity was significantly worse for recipients in year three, a result that does not survive False Discovery Rate adjustment.

AI Summary. Public schools in heavily Democratic areas often stayed closed for close to a year, while schools in some Republican areas reopened after only the initial spring closure. Eight of the 10 states with the largest losses in student achievement since 2019 voted Democratic in recent presidential elections, and eight of the 10 with the smallest math shortfalls voted Republican.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

.@DLeonhardt reports a sharp partisan gap in learning loss: 8 of the 10 states with the biggest math declines since 2019 – likely due to prolonged school closures – voted Democratic, while 8 of the 10 smallest shortfalls voted Republican.

Do longer school closures explain larger student achievement losses?

Core argument: Eight of the 10 states that have lost the most ground in test scores since 2019 voted Democratic in recent presidential elections, while eight of the 10 states with the smallest math shortfalls voted Republican.

Many public schools in heavily Democratic areas stayed closed for almost a year — from the spring of 2020 until the spring of 2021. In some Republican areas, by contrast, schools remained closed for only the spring of 2020. Eight of the 10 states that have lost the most ground since 2019 voted Democratic in recent presidential elections. And eight of the 10 states with the smallest math shortfalls voted Republican. [Higher initial scores don’t] explain the post-pandemic patterns. For example, New Jersey (a blue state) and Utah (a red state) both had high math scores in 2019, but New Jersey has fared much worse since then.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Eight of the 10 states that have lost the most ground in test scores since 2019 voted Democratic in recent presidential elections, while eight of the 10 states with the smallest math shortfalls voted Republican.
  2. Many public schools in heavily Democratic areas stayed closed from the spring of 2020 until the spring of 2021, whereas schools in some Republican areas were closed only for the spring of 2020.
  3. Higher initial scores do not explain the post-pandemic patterns: New Jersey and Utah both had high math scores in 2019, but New Jersey has fared much worse since.

AI Summary. Long-running U.S. tests show population average reading scores moved from 255 to 256 out of 500 and math from 266 to 271, despite educational attainment rising more than three years. The author argues that if added schooling has not raised productivity, measured total factor productivity growth has been understated, shrinking the apparent "Great Stagnation" by about a third.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

.@MTabarrok argues that “zero improvement in the population average score” in math and reading since the 1970s implies that growth accounting has overestimated growth in human capital, understating 2023 TFP relative to its post-1973 trend by up to ⅓.

Has productivity growth been understated because added schooling didn't raise skills?

Core argument: Average U.S. reading scores moved from 255 out of 500 in 1971 to 256 in 2023 and math scores from 266 to 271, essentially zero improvement despite educational attainment rising 3+ years since the 1970s.

Math and reading scores on tests that have been surveyed over longer periods also show essentially zero improvement in the population average scores. The average score on the reading test in 1971 was 255 out of 500, in 2023 it was 256 and math scores went from 266 to 271. Educational attainment has risen by 3+ years since 1970s but population level reading and math scores have barely changed, and scores within educational attainment groups have fallen. As more people are pushed through lowered standards to a high school diploma, the wage premium to this degree has fallen, suggesting that much of its value was in the differentiating signal rather than skill gains. If this story is true, and more education hasn’t been raising productivity, then all the GDP growth we thought was due to more skilled workers is actually coming from somewhere else. That means we’ve been undercounting TFP, and technological progress for decades. If we take the SF Fed TFP data and remove the adjustments they make for gains in human capital (based mostly on rising educational attainment), we get something that looks like this. The Great Stagnation is shrunk by about a third!

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Average U.S. reading scores moved from 255 out of 500 in 1971 to 256 in 2023 and math scores from 266 to 271, essentially zero improvement despite educational attainment rising 3+ years since the 1970s.
  2. Scores within educational attainment groups have fallen, and the wage premium to a high school diploma has declined as more people are pushed through lowered standards, suggesting much of the diploma's value was differentiating signal rather than skill gains.
  3. Removing the SF Fed's human capital adjustments, based mostly on rising educational attainment, from its total factor productivity data shrinks the Great Stagnation by about a third, implying TFP and technological progress have been undercounted for decades.

AI Summary. Chicago spends more than $24,000 per student on public schools, up 107%, while reading and math proficiency in grades 3–8 fell 63% and 78%; the city has led the nation in homicides for 12 consecutive years. Its population has declined for nine straight years as almost half the city budget goes to debt service and public pensions.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

.@GeorgeWill argues, “Chicago’s population has declined for 9 consecutive years as education has cratered, crime has soared, and public services have withered because almost 1/2 of the city budget goes to debt service and government employees’ pensions.”

Has higher school spending in a big city improved student outcomes?

Core argument: Chicago public school spending has risen 107% since 2012 to more than $24,000 per student, excluding debt service and capital expenditures, while grades 3–8 proficiency fell 63% in reading and 78% in math.

Spending on public schools (more than $24,000 per student, not counting debt service and capital expenditures) has increased 107% since 2012, but proficiency in reading and math in grades 3-8 plummeted 63% and 78%, respectively. Crime is higher than in any other major U.S. city. Year-on-year, robberies are up 21%, assaults 7%, violent crimes in schools 26%. Chicago has led the nation in number of homicides for 12 consecutive years. The [Illinois Policy Institute] says Chicago’s population has shrunk by more than a quarter since it peaked in 1950; in 2023, the city hit its lowest point since 1920. Chicago’s population has declined for nine consecutive years as education has cratered, crime has soared, and public services have withered because almost half of the city budget goes to debt service and government employees’ pensions. These have been negotiated with government sitting on both sides of the table: its employees demanding that it do what it wants to do — grow. The steep price of this progressivism is disproportionately paid by its supposed beneficiaries.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Chicago public school spending has risen 107% since 2012 to more than $24,000 per student, excluding debt service and capital expenditures, while grades 3–8 proficiency fell 63% in reading and 78% in math.
  2. Chicago's crime is higher than in any other major U.S. city, with robberies up 21%, assaults up 7%, and violent crimes in schools up 26% year-on-year, and the city has led the nation in homicides for 12 consecutive years.
  3. The Illinois Policy Institute says Chicago's population has shrunk by more than a quarter since its 1950 peak, declining for nine consecutive years and hitting its lowest point since 1920 in 2023, while almost half the city budget goes to debt service and government employee pensions.

AI Summary. Nationwide chronic absenteeism — the share of students missing at least 10% of a school year — rose from 15% in 2018 to 28% in 2022, and although rates improved in 2023, they remained 75% above the pre-pandemic baseline. Chronic absenteeism is associated with lower standardized test scores, with the highest rates in lower-achieving, higher-poverty districts.

Date Posted:
Is Database:
Database
Is Important:
Important

28% of American public school students missed at least 10% of the school year in 2022 up from 15% before the pandemic. The change was most pronounced in low-achieving school districts. @natmalkus @AEIecon

Has chronic school absenteeism remained far above pre-pandemic levels?

Core argument: Nationwide chronic absenteeism—students missing at least 10% of a school year—rose from 15% in 2018 to 28% in 2022, and although rates fell in 33 of 39 reporting states in 2023, they remained 75% above the pre-pandemic baseline.

Chronic absenteeism is associated with lower standardized test scores. Studies have shown larger associations between chronic absenteeism and achievement in later grades than in earlier grades and in math than in reading. Nationwide, chronic absenteeism—the percentage of students missing at least 10% of a school year—surged from 15% in 2018 to 28% in 2022. Falling in 33 of 39 states reporting data, chronic absenteeism rates improved in 2023 but still remained 75% higher than the pre-pandemic baseline. Chronic absenteeism increased for all district types, but rates were highest in districts with low achievement and higher poverty, affecting over one in three students. In 2022, 16% of Asian students and 24% of white students were chronically absent, compared to 36% of Hispanic students and 39% of black students. The urgent need to recover from pandemic learning loss will be severely hampered by current rates of chronic absenteeism, making it the most pressing post-pandemic problem in public schools.

Takeaways by Macro Roundup® AI

  1. Nationwide chronic absenteeism—students missing at least 10% of a school year—rose from 15% in 2018 to 28% in 2022, and although rates fell in 33 of 39 reporting states in 2023, they remained 75% above the pre-pandemic baseline.
  2. Chronic absenteeism in 2022 reached 39% of black students and 36% of Hispanic students, compared with 24% of white students and 16% of Asian students.
  3. Chronic absenteeism, which is associated with lower standardized test scores, rose across all district types but was highest in districts with low achievement and higher poverty, affecting more than one in three students there.